The first of my weekly analyses of the fourth tier focuses on the many surprises thrown up in the early exchanges at both ends of the standings.
It’s reasonable to suggest that Bradford City have underperformed whilst adjusting to life back down in League Two. Gary Bowyer has tried out four distinct shapes in the opening half-dozen encounters, and has lamented the loss of all-rounder Jamie Devitt to the sidelines for at least a fortnight. The injury might, however, help to reduce the amount of tinkering he’s willing or able to do for the foreseeable future, starting with the clash at home with Northampton Town. The Bantams have ranked high in the number of shots thus far but close to bottom with those that have been on target (in the bottom four with both Wyscout and WhoScored), and could do with that changing quickly in front of a sizeable crowd against the visitors.
Keith Curle has stressed the importance of nullifying the threats the hosts possess in their ranks to further frustrate the slightly restless support. The Cobblers enjoyed a superb win over much-fancied Plymouth Argyle in their last outing, with Andy Williams bagging a brace as the focal point of the attack from a pair of Sam Hoskins’ crosses. However, they’ve had a similarly disappointing start to 2019/2020 overall, and Nicky Adams has yet to notch an assist despite an xA of 2.28 (third in the league) – I’d imagine that will change in a fixture that will emphasise pushing wide to create chances.
Cambridge United boss Colin Calderwood will be hoping his proclamation that “lessons have been learned” from their insipid defeat to Port Vale rings true. Whilst not yet living up to their billing from 2018/2019, Forest Green Rovers are likely to dominate possession once more, which could mean a repeat of chasing shadows for a second week. The performance and competition for places could mean a number of changes are made. The centre back pairing of George Taft and Greg Taylor have laid on more passes than anyone else in the squad, and they’ll need those balls to be accurate from defence to prevent being camped in their own third for long spells.
The Nailsworth outfit have not translated their time in control to goals thus far, not even striking once per game. Custodian Jojo Wollacott’s dismissal after half an hour last time out was the chief reason for drawing a blank; Mark Cooper has praised the quality of his attack-minded players in the lead-up to tomorrow, and there ought to be opportunities to climb off the foot of both the touches in the box and shots taken tables, and moreover, earn a convincing win to (temporarily) silence any doubt.
Stephen Pressley has been keen to stress he’s “doing everything he can to maximise the group”, and you once again feel that for Carlisle United to prosper, they’ll have to avoid lay-offs to their small squad… and the likes of versatile forward Hallam Hope to be fully concentrating on the task in hand. That should be an easier task now that the transfer window has closed and he remains in situ, but the Cumbrians have to halt the chances and goals they give up – they were extremely fortunate to keep a clean sheet against Scunthorpe United, losing the xG battle 1.98-0.18!
Stefan Scougall has gleaned two in five from the left side of central midfield, but is a big doubt for the visit of Exeter City. The Grecians are the early pace-setters, with a two-point cushion over their nearest rivals. Nicky Law always looks a class act down the left channel, but even more impressive has been Aaron Martin, especially since being shifted inside as the anchoring centre back in the three. It is partly on the back of his aerial prowess and reading of the game that have aided in their quest to shut out the opposition, making more defensive interceptions collectively than any other team. It will be intriguing to see how he organises his partners when they make the mammoth trip tomorrow, being matched man-for-man by Carlisle’s frontline.
Cheltenham Town have carried their excellent form (particularly at home) into the current campaign, crashing in eight goals in three league fixtures at the Jonny-Rocks Stadium. New signing Jonte Smith will be keen to get in on the action, having eschewed the opportunity to help Bermuda in the CONCACAF Nations League during the international break to ensure his transfer could go ahead without any hitches. Assistant manager Russell Milton took questions this week prior to the Stevenage encounter, much of which centred around what Smith will bring to the group, as well as citing the treatment table list for the Hertfordshire club’s travails up to this point.
Dino Maamria has challenged his troops “to put everything aside” as they seek their maiden victory. He’s rotated personnel in attack to address the string of ‘nils’ against their name, and they were unlucky not to bag a win over Macclesfield Town last weekend. The recent captures of Craig Mackail-Smith and Adam El-Abd add oodles of experience and game management to what was hitherto one of the younger rosters in League Two, although the former might have to settle for a place among the substitutes after Kurtis Guthrie got off the mark.
Callum Harriott has rejoined Colchester United after having a loan spell in Essex several seasons ago. His signing will add even more pace down the flanks, and John McGreal will be banking on it serving as another positive step in their recovery in League Two. Opposition managers are all too aware of the threats at their disposal, and the U’s propensity to get caught offside is testament to that.
Walsall chief Darrell Clarke has been channelling his inner Arsène Wenger ahead of the game, pointing to ‘mental strength’ as the key in shaking off a decidedly indifferent start. Picking the final pass forward has also been a problem – right winger Rory Holden needs more helps from the likes of Danny Guthrie in supplying the front two. The Saddlers rank bottom for key passes created.
Grimsby Town have blasted in 13 goals in six matches to date, and the deadliness of target man James Hanson, scoring half of his 10 shots on target. Granted, two have been penalties, but that takes nothing away from his personal and The Mariners’ rejuvenation in 2019/2020; his presence has been a constant thorn for defences, and at a bare minimum, he has had at least two efforts every match. Set pieces have been a huge part of their superb start, but Michael Jolley believes the “toughest test of the season so far” lies in wait tomorrow when Crewe Alexandra travel eastwards. His adversary for the weekend, David Artell, was effusive in his praise for Jolley, having coached together for the Alex U16s at an earlier stage in their respective careers.
The maturing Railwaymen were able to retain most of their brighter young talents from the previous term, and were at least the equals in terms of xG in the two defeats they have suffered to date (the 3-0 reverse against Plymouth was by no means an accurate reflection of that match). There are few better in the division in the six-yard area than veteran Chris Porter, who can count on Charlie Kirk on his immediate left to ping accurate balls to him.
Leyton Orient are yet another side with a 2-2-2 record, and head coach Ross Embleton believes they “are small margins away” from improving their results on the road. In the immediate future, they will look to do that back at base when they entertain Swindon Town. Josh Wright has proved to be a shrewd acquisition, adding goals and know-how from deep in midfield; the main issue remains conceding big chances that have undermined the low overall number, and this is surely not going to change tomorrow.
The Robins will be backed by a sold-out away end, and first-team coach Tommy Wright expects there to be plenty of goals to entertain them. ‘Wellensball’ has them three points off the top, with the loanee strike partnership of Eoin Doyle and Jerry Yates plundering eight between them. The progressive, riskier passing employed by the Wiltshire outfit is hard to defend against, doubly so when backed up by enterprising wingplay.
Macclesfield Town have continued their promising opening under new manager Daryl McMahon, already accruing nearly a quarter of the points likely to be required for survival as a minimum. Ben Stephens, who can play both up top and as a #10, has been instrumental in their form, acting both as chief creator as well as chipping in with his share of the goals.
Crawley Town are also faring much better than most pundits would’ve anticipated. Gabriele Cioffi is understandably pleased with both the application of his players and the depth at his disposal, the latter of which he added to earlier this week with the signings of Denzeil Boadu and Gyliano van Velzen, and he will be keen to see how they fare tomorrow – Reece Grego-Cox’s place on the right of the three looks most under threat.
It’s hard to recall a time in recent seasons where it hasn’t felt as though the manager of Mansfield Town‘s position is under serious scrutiny. Lying 19th at the table even at this early stage is unlikely to be tolerated for long, but thankfully for John Dempster, Ryan Sweeney’s red card against Exeter City has been rescinded. Sweeney is one of several big names that have not lived up to their billing, which has collectively overshadowed Danny Rose’s fine return in front of goal. Dempster is pinning his hopes on “the Stags soaring” against surprise bottom side Scunthorpe United.
Paul Hurst has endured a torrid opening to his stint in charge, hampered in some ways by injuries – his latest interview on the official site makes for grim reading in terms of expecting many of them making a return in the immediate future. Loanee George Miller has spoken of the need “for a chance to fall for him” to get off the mark, but his game has always been about making a nuisance of himself to create his own opportunities. Rory McArdle’s contribution cannot be sniffed at, but his effectiveness in the air at both ends has not led to much in the way of points.
Morecambe stalwart Jim Bentley has reverted the formation to a 4-4-2 since a costly couple of fixtures that kicked off 2019/2020. This had the desired effect temporarily until reverting to type in the past fortnight. Barry Roche, for so long one of the most reliable goalkeepers in the basement division, has not been at his best, and a solution must be found to plug the gaps if another long season of struggle is to be avoided. Lewis Alessandra’s made the most of his scant chances to date, scoring each of his four shots on target. He should get some further opportunities at home to Salford City.
The Ammies have given up triple figures already, facing 104 shots, by far and away the worst record in the league. Thankfully, that hasn’t translated into comparatively many goals conceded, and Jack Baldwin, on loan from Sunderland, is sure to take his place in the heart of the defence as a countermeasure to that particular stat. Jake Jervis joins a strong-looking forward line, but at present, it’s too easy to pass through their midfield.
Newport County are one of two sides to remain unbeaten in League Two at the time of writing. Rodney Parade has been a fortress for sometime, whilst on the road, they have ground out points when not performing at their zenith against opponents at least their equals on paper. Michael Flynn is adamant that the division “will be the most competitive it’s been in a long time”, something I’m also of the view of, and anticipates another bruising battle with Port Vale.
The Valiants have become tougher to beat under John Askey, who is hoping to take advantage of the Exiles’ absentees tomorrow. It’s no longer simply a case of hitting it to club legend Tom Pope and hoping for the best, as there now exists more depth and devilment in attack. Jordan Archer will be pushing for a place, and he takes up similar positions to Pope but with a change of pace. David Amoo helps to stretch defences that would otherwise remain pretty compact, and that will be the most interesting aspect during tomorrow’s game.
Plymouth Argyle boss Ryan Lowe has been quick to temper any notion of Jose Baxter “getting one over” the latter’s former employers, Oldham Athletic. Both manager and player have not seen things go all their own way in 2019/2020. As is now typical for a Lowe side, most of their attacks have come down the left channel (42%), with the middle relatively underutilised. It should serve as no surprise that they’ve also conceded the bulk down their left, and will have to get much closer to the winger. Chris Eagles should provide them with that chance if selected.
It’s been another term of off-the-pitch machinations overshadowing results on it, which have also been hard to come by so far. Head coach Laurent Banide will be hoping deadline day signing Filipe Morais’ return to Boundary Park will help inject the dressing room with a much-needed boost. The strikers have a single goal between them, and although Chris O’Grady’s departure to neighbours Bolton Wanderers was far from lamented, it has highlighted the lack of a potent target man in their ranks to finish off Gevaro Nepomuceno’s floated crosses.
Like what you’ve read? Support me on Patreon for just $3 a month!
In a perpetual state of cutting it extremely fine, the future of Bury Football Club is still precarious at the time of writing. The events of the past week have at once felt like a whirlwind and running in treacle, amplified by belated but constant national media attention. Many of the club’s supporters have taken to the airwaves to highlight the (ongoing) plight, and yours truly has been no exception to that:
The previously intransigent owner Steve Dale was sending all kinds of mixed messages on Friday during his grand tour of seemingly everywhere except the negotiating table, with as many as four interested parties in taking over before the midnight deadline set by the EFL for either sufficient evidence of proof of funds from Dale himself or for a deal to be struck to their satisfaction.
Like probably every other fan, I was glued to social media (even more than usual) as the minutes ticked by, desperate for some solid sleep but even more desperate for a credible source to break the news that there had been a sale, which duly came a little over two hours from oblivion:
Understand @buryfcofficial owner Steve Dale has accepted a takeover offer from a London-based group and is in process of notifying the @EFL – as yet unconfirmed.
What quickly emerged from then on were the identities of the group – C&N Sporting Risk, a small company whose main service is in data analytics, with Rory Campbell and Henry Newman at the head of the firm.
Campbell is the son of the infamous Labour spin-doctor Alastair, who, for all his… flaws (putting it extremely lightly) has always maintained a fervent and genuine interest in football, being a follower of fellow Lancashire side Burnley and raising a family with an appreciable knowledge of how important the link is between clubs and the communities they are an intrinsic component of.
Rory has created his own niche after completing the well-trodden Oxbridge PPE path, founding C&N in 2016 whilst still in his 20s after firming up his interests at university, with the ongoing ‘Moneyball’ experiment at Brentford a big driver behind his deepening involvement in the sport (and perhaps the current interest in Bury). It’s impossible to ignore the betting aspect of his company, however, and there would be a question mark over just how they could as a business work around the strict laws set out by the FA governing inside information whilst owning a club. He would need to prove, much like Tony Bloom at Brighton & Hove Albion and Matthew Benham at The Bees that he doesn’t place any bets himself, only acting as a ‘consultant’ for others.
Newman’s background is more rooted in coaching, especially in London with two different clubs – Charlton Athletic and Barnet, the latter of which he had a brief spell as joint-interim coach with Rossi Eames two years ago, and the pair appeared on a Not the Top 20 podcast during their brief tenure:
In it, Henry sets out his vision for how football should be played, with an emphasis on an eye-pleasing style whilst still being mindful of the shortcomings of the squad he had under him at The Hive. He took a break from a role as chief opposition scout with West Ham United during that four-month interlude, continuing to hone and diversify his skillset in the game and firmly setting him on the road to his directorship at C&N.
At this juncture, it’s important not to get too far ahead of myself. A disappointingly short extension to the deadline, in C&N’s collective view, was granted by the EFL yesterday, providing only a single extra business day to conclude the deal (or at least 99% of it). Doubtlessly, between Stewart Day and Steve Dale, a complex web was woven for any future prospective owners to cut through and unravel simultaneously. A debt of gratitude is nevertheless owed by many to a few select people – the half-dozen or so at the head of Forever Bury, local MP James Frith, and even the likes of Ron Wood and former chairman Terry Robinson in the background.
One final thing to note right now is that whilst I can claim to have no insider knowledge of the wealth (or otherwise) of C&N, they have already provided to the EFL what Dale could not in terms of proof of funds. Moreover, their pursuit of a deal has been 10 weeks in the making, only coming to a head thanks to Dale relenting at the last possible moment… and crucially, well before the CVA had even been tabled, let alone approved.
@JamesFrith James – How can I contact you directly to discuss the ownership status of Bury FC please? Have been in discussions with Directors over the last few days and have seen your intervention over the last few days in the media.
Hopefully, this won’t prove to be another false dawn (and subsequently the footnote) in Bury’s proud, if often financially fraught, 134-year history. The Gigg Lane faithful don’t want the moon, just a club to continue supporting to pass on to the generations to come.
This season, owing to certain circumstances and my new-found profession as a freelance writer, I’ve taken the opportunity to write team-by-team previews for every League One and Two side over on We Love Betting UK:
As at Christmas, I canvassed opinion on social media, grouping the grades as follows: A-B are good, C-D are okay, and E-F are poor. The grades are only a reflection of every player’s on-pitch performance, rather than their heroic stoicism off to it to continue performing without full pay since the end of February:
**IMPORTANT NOTE**: The ‘What Next’ for every player makes the assumption that a resolution of some kind will be found to the current shambles off the pitch with regard to finances and the immediate future of the football club… otherwise, there wouldn’t be much point including those sections!
1. Joe Murphy
Total Games / Total Minutes: 52 / 5,074
Goals Conceded: 65
Clean Sheets: 13
Assessment: Surprisingly voted by his peers in the PFA League Two Team of the Season, the veteran custodian didn’t miss a minute of league action, brushing off his injury problems from the previous term. The emphasis on quick and short distribution out from the back suited his style very well indeed. He made the odd glaring error as you’d expect from any guardian – allowing former Shaker Danny Rose to rob him of the ball in the home encounter with Mansfield Town to tap into the empty net sticks out in particular. That mishap has to be balanced with often being the very last line of defence in one-on-one situations, and he performed admirably in those cases, saving brilliantly from James Norwood at Prenton Park to ensure parity was kept and promotion was sealed.
Not the tallest or most aerially confident, coming for floated crosses and dead balls into the area were his weaker aspects throughout the campaign, and he conceded more than many other members of the ‘union’, hence a large contingent of fans’ shock at his award. Solid but often unspectacular, his presence on and off the pitch as the oldest individual in the dressing room proved to be a steady influence over the course of 2018/2019.
What Next: He’s harboured ambitions of going into goalkeeper coaching for a couple of years now. At 37, he probably still has at least another season of playing should he be offered another deal. Whether that’s in BL9 or with his #1 spot quite so assured I’m much less certain of.
2. Tom Miller
Total Games / Total Minutes: 15 / 936
Goals Scored: 0
Goals Assisted: 0
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right wing-back / Right-sided centre back in a three / Right-back
Assessment: Started the season as the right-back of choice in a conservative 4-3-2-1, but an early injury likely hastened Lowe’s plans to adopt a more attacking posture. Frequently spotted on the bench thereafter, he had good cameos in the EFL Trophy in a number of roles that ably demonstrated his versatility. At wing-back, his style was in stark contrast to Nicky Adams when rarely afforded the chance, joining in less often in the sweeping moves forward. Additionally, he won plenty of headers down his flank when direct balls were lobbed in search of a nippy winger.
What Next: Still has a year left to run on his contract. Being pushed to a definitive third place in the pecking order by Adams and Ryan Cooney (a decade his junior) must have rankled him somewhat, but if so, there were never any public signs of it. More at ease in a flat back four, he’s an ill fit for a swashbuckling ‘score one more than the opposition’ mentality, but equally, his versatility is important. If the numbers on the roster are cut as expected, he might want to make the most of guaranteed first team football elsewhere as part of the group heading for the exit door.
3. Chris Stokes
Total Games / Total Minutes: 43 / 3,697
Goals Scored: 4
Goals Assisted: 0
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left-sided centre back in a three / Left wing-back / Left-back
Assessment: The former Coventry City defender had quite the arc in his maiden campaign in white and royal blue. Like Miller, he started out at full-back before being pushed forward briefly. The emergence of Callum McFadzean saw him take up a less familiar left-sided centre back with mixed results. His lack of raw speed and physicality saw him beaten often in the air and on the turn when the opposition looked to press the Shakers in their own half to prevent an easy out-ball from their own third. His nadir came in the breathtaking comeback win over Milton Keynes Dons, having a big hand in all three strikes for the visitors (including an unfortunate own goal).
The loan signing of Scott Wharton late in the winter transfer window seemed to have put paid to his season, but he had an amazing renaissance in April, bagging a brace against Carlisle United and another goal with a superb volley at the far post to start the fightback versus Northampton Town, demonstrating a different sort of threat at left-wing back to McFadzean.
What Next: In his prime and with one more year at the club, I can see him staying and being at the very least a good candidate from the bench to call upon to either shore things up at the back or to give something different down the left.
4. Will Aimson
Total Games / Total Minutes: 43 / 3,940
Goals Scored: 4
Goals Assisted: 3
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right-sided centre back in a three / Middle centre back in a three
Assessment: From the get-go, he was instructed to stay wider than most conventional centre backs do in a three-man backline, covering in behind Adams’ many bursts forward up the right flank. This was both a blessing and a curse for the former Blackpool stopper; it gave his teammates the reassurance to push onward, but made his distribution suffer somewhat, restricted in some ways to clipping passes down the channel for the strikers to run onto. Aerial prowess was on show in both boxes, scoring four times from set pieces, none more emphatically than the third equaliser at home to Lincoln City, gaining some small measure of ‘revenge’ for his harsh red card in the reverse fixture.
In the run-in, he took injections in his groin to get through the hectic schedule, which resulted in several early withdrawals from games and time on the sidelines. An unheralded member of the squad relatively speaking, his contributions didn’t go unnoticed by the more discerning observers.
What Next: His appearance makes you think he’s much older than just 25, but, with a year on his contract to run, he’s one of the best assets likely to remain at Gigg Lane into 2019/2020. Can only improve with time, and might be a more central figure in the defence to boot.
5. Adam Thompson
Total Games / Total Minutes: 54 / 5,102
Goals Scored: 2
Goals Assisted: 2
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Middle centre back in a three / Left-sided centre back in a three / Right-sided centre back in a three
Assessment: The pick of the bunch from a defensive point of view. Thompson’s travails last season are well-known, and he alluded to them during a Q&A for this blog. Almost immediately asked to be the all-important middleman in a backline often matched in terms of numbers on the counter, he had few truly poor outings in a year where he played the most of any Bury player. Not the most adept at combatting target men (a problem he shared with his cohorts), he nevertheless always gave as good as he got, being sometimes the only assured presence in front of Murphy. An accurate passer, he might be a tad disappointed not to have got more goals with his intelligent runs in dead ball situations, but showed great composure in the snow against Oxford United in the EFL Trophy to rifle home on the volley.
He was rewarded for his displays by occasionally receiving the captain’s armband, and he really was the glue that held together the defence far more than the goals conceded stat might suggest.
What Next: A swift return to third tier football and one of the more well-regarded centre backs this season in the league, a recall to the Northern Ireland national team setup is not beyond the realms of possibility. It wouldn’t surprise if that happened, and by the same token, if other sides were interested in his services, being at a good age and entering the final year of his contract.
6. Eoghan O’Connell
Total Games / Total Minutes: 35 / 2,278
Goals Scored: 3
Goals Assisted: 2
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Middle centre back in a three / Right-sided centre back in a three / Defensive midfielder in a three
Assessment: The mixed grading by fellow fans above signify that the Irishman had an up and down campaign. Physically, he’s the closest the club have to a dominating defender, and would certainly be the top candidate for isolating a lone striker in the air. On the ground is a different matter entirely, however, which is where the mixed results are borne out; when faced with speed, he can look more than a touch cumbersome, especially on the turn. On the other hand, when the team needs to take the initiative, which they almost always did by default under Lowe, his quality on the ball is there for all to see, with his often surgical through passes helping the whole backline advance up to 10 yards. There’s even an argument that he’s the best passer in the squad on his day, such is the difference he can and has made on numerous occasions.
What Next: Subject of serious interest from Coventry City in the winter transfer window, his prime is still some way off. Used in defensive midfield because of the aforementioned passing range, the biggest conundrum he faces is where he should be consider his go-to role, lacking the speed required for a two-man central defence, or to plow a lone furrow as an anchor in front of the back three/four in a counter-attacking outfit, as that could expose the shortcomings in his game.
7. Nicky Adams
Total Games / Total Minutes: 53 / 4,553
Goals Scored: 3
Goals Assisted: 15
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right wing-back / Right-wing in a four
Assessment: I’ll be the first to admit I was a bit sceptical about his return to the club for a third spell, given the lengthy injury spell caused by a damaged anterior cruciate ligament at Carlisle United… and was then utterly perplexed when Lowe shifted him backwards to be a right wing-back after Miller’s own time on the treatment table began. However, it soon became abundantly clear that there was method to the apparent madness, and under the manager he also calls a dear friend, the mutual faith and trust was rewarded, being tasked with playing more like a conventional winger than anything. Putting in the most crosses of anyone in the division yielded the highest assist total in the EFL. Injuries have curtailed a bit of his speed, but he has found ways to combat that, adding probing corners and free-kicks to his repertoire over the last few years.
Stellar displays were always likely to peter out at some stage in the term, but he could never be accused of lacking effort when things weren’t working out as he’d planned.
What Next: It can’t be underestimated how much the vice-captain did for the cause, nor will it have gone unnoticed that he appeared in the second most number of matches in total. His consistently high number of assists will always have other outfits interested in a transfer, but he’s only likely to leave if events off the field conspire to offer him little alternative.
10. Danny Mayor
Total Games / Total Minutes: 44 / 4,143
Goals Scored: 12
Goals Assisted: 9
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left-sided central midfielder in a three / Attacking midfielder in a four / Left-wing in a four
Assessment: Another to silence the doubters, lower league fans were treated to the sorts of displays that reminded them precisely why he’s such a joy to watch. The inside forward took a few matches (like the rest of the squad) to truly get motoring, but once he did, he was unplayable for large swathes of the season in a narrower, deeper position than he’s occupied previously as the nominal left-sided central midfielder. His dribbles from deep always gave his teammates hope that he could conjure something from nothing, which he conspired to do with pleasing regularity, whether benefitting from his own superb close control or by laying off the ball to a free man after dragging his marker horizontally across the pitch.
With such a special talent, the team will inevitably be weaker when he’s not in the lineup, as his needless, costly dismissal at home to Swindon Town proved, making him miss three matches with the worst disciplinary record in the side (some of which, like that incident, can be reasoned away by the number of fouls he suffered). His predictability in his movements on the ball did not necessarily translate into making him any easier to stop, and he was nominated for League Two Player of the Season again, losing out to Norwood, but can console himself by his inclusions in both official team selections.
What Next: Out of contract and almost certainly off elsewhere, which, after six seasons in south Lancashire, you could hardly begrudge him for. The key for him will be finding another manager like Lowe who will treat him in much the same way. Individuals have different needs in terms of support, and my hope for him is he can be a central component of another team’s plans whilst receiving the same sort of attention he’s experienced at Bury.
11. Jordan Rossiter
Total Games / Total Minutes: 16 / 1,593
Goals Scored: 1
Goals Assisted: 1
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Defensive midfielder in a three / Right-sided central midfielder in a three / Left-sided central midfielder in a three
Assessment: Another to assuage fears of breaking down on the pitch and in some style, too. The Glasgow Rangers regista was a ‘massive coup’ according to Lowe when he signed on loan during the winter transfer window, and once more, the gamble was vindicated. His start on the half-frozen pitch against Crawley Town wasn’t the most auspicious, from then on, he hardly erred, being precisely what was missing in defensive situations – someone who could intercept loose passes, win second balls, and redistribute with purpose.
Plying your trade in defensive midfield is probably the best way of going unheralded in the modern game, but it was his vision that stood out most about him, a perception shared by anyone who bore witness to his exploits for the Shakers. He’s never going to be relied upon for what he can do in the final third – that’s not his forté; that said, he capped off his temporary arrangement with a peach of a goal on final day, bending in a stunning effort from outside the area.
What Next: Steven Gerrard will be delighted with how he performed, and must surely have wormed his way back into contention for the Old Firm outfit. A return next season looks unlikely for several reasons, and if he is loaned out once more, expect it to be to a side in the Championship.
15. Byron Moore
Total Games / Total Minutes: 44 / 2,758
Goals Scored: 8
Goals Assisted: 3
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right-sided striker in a two / Left wing-back / Right wing-back
Assessment: A surprise package in the sense that Lowe found an elegant solution to the absence of conventional wingers. Moore, hitherto almost always found on the right flank, carved a very specific niche of his own up top, which came to the fore before the signature of Maynard when there were fewer options to choose from. Important strikes in tricky away fixtures at Swindon Town and Colchester United respectively set the tone for having an important say in the course of the campaign. The nature of his playstyle and unfamiliarity with the requirements of a striker did at times mean he cut a frustrated figure, not always in sync with his partner.
The Plan B for him was to come on in place of McFadzean at left wing-back in an even bolder strategy based on camping in the opposition’s third and working the space in tandem with Mayor to get in behind. It didn’t always come off because it sometimes appeared as though they were occupying the exact same area, but it did signify a greater degree of tactical flexibility on Lowe’s part than any recent predecessor to his post.
What Next: Should stick around for a second season, and might have more consistent starts if the likes of Mayor and Maynard do move on. Positional versatility will be of even greater importance in a trimmed down roster.
16. Ryan Cooney
Total Games / Total Minutes: 14 / 809
Goals Scored: 0
Goals Assisted: 1
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right wing-back / Right-sided centre back in a three / Right-back / Left wing-back
Assessment: Slowly but surely made his way into the frame over the nine months, eventually having the honour of being one of the youngest captains in the club’s 134-year history bestowed upon him for the last fixture of the campaign. Cooney’s rise is built upon a solid work ethic and a willingness to follow instructions and play where asked to. Better in the air than would probably appear, his stand-out performance came at right wing-back in the narrow EFL Trophy triumph over Mansfield Town, thwarting almost every sojourn down the channel. Steady performances ensured more minutes were afforded to him in the run-in, and he strikes a good balance between defence and attack when out wide.
What Next: Will probably be another mainstay on the bench from the get-go, having proven his worth in the difficult transition from U18s regular to the fringes of the first team over the course of the past year and a half. Intrigued to see how he will grasp his second full campaign as a professional in 2019/2020.
18. Dom Telford
Total Games / Total Minutes: 48 / 2,444
Goals Scored: 14
Goals Assisted: 5
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right-sided striker in a two / Attacking midfielder in a four
Assessment: Finishing top scorer in the EFL Trophy was a double-edged sword for the striker, who gleaned half of his haul from the unpopular competition, as was the regular rotation in league games he was prone to being a victim of. Lowe showed more tactical nous in having him usually on the right side of the two, despite very much being a left-footed player. This gave Adams free rein to get forward unhindered, as well as frequently giving Telford’s marker pause for thought as he had the pace to dribble into central areas from a starting position well before the 18 yard line.
Described as a ‘fox in the box’ by his manager upon signing, he showed there was more than one bow on his strong with his diligence outside of it, possessing a low centre of gravity to compensate for his lack of height. This was seen before Maynard arrived, and the pair formed a good understanding, knowing in which context to stay close to one another and when to split to create openings.
What Next: 14 goals is an impressive number for any forward, especially for a player whose ratio was better than one in two. Could be the main man in attack next season if not subject to strong interest from elsewhere in the EFL. A major success story of 2018/2019 without question.
19. Scott Wharton
Total Games / Total Minutes: 15 / 1,266
Goals Scored: 2
Goals Assisted: 1
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left-sided centre back in a three / Middle centre back in a three
Assessment: Parent club Blackburn Rovers recalled him from his season-long deal with Lincoln, disappointed that he wasn’t able to cement a first team place (it should be said he had extremely stiff rivals for a berth). Cian Bolger’s permanent arrival at Sincil Bank compounded matters, so Wharton was instead farmed out to fellow promotion candidates Bury. His 15-game stint has divided opinion somewhat – he, like the rest of team, looked utterly bereft of confidence in that three match losing streak during April, giving the ball away ridiculously cheaply. In other instances, he’s appeared a calmer, taller replacement for Stokes as left-sided centre back.
Goals in successive fixtures signalled his ability to be on the receiving end of dead balls, and when he was at his best, he shut down plenty of attacks in the half-space.
What Next: Reasonably successful seasons in the fourth tier should persuade Tony Mowbray to offer him to established League One clubs. I don’t foresee one of them being the Shakers.
21. Callum McFadzean
Total Games / Total Minutes: 50 / 4,213
Goals Scored: 0
Goals Assisted: 7
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left wing-back / Left-sided centre back in a three / Left-back
Assessment: Like Moore, he performed way above my modest expectations. Didn’t arrive at the club with the best of reputations, and ‘released from Guiseley’, rightly or wrongly, did colour many supporters’ perceptions. Had a slightly shaky introduction at left wing-back, but then made the role his own with increasingly consistent showings, being almost as reliable with his low crosses as his counterpart Adams on the opposite flank with floated ones. No mean feat!
Might be slightly disappointed to be the only regular outfielder not to trouble the scoresheet – he certainly went close on a number of occasions. The self-confessed ‘better at attacking than defending’ belied his own statement throughout the campaign, and his goal-saving tackle at Forest Green Rovers after his own error was a sight to behold, running at full pelt to make amends. Formed an on-pitch rapport with Mayor not too dissimilar to the one the latter enjoyed with Chris Hussey.
What Next: One of the few out of contract individuals that under normal circumstances, the club would be desperate to keep hold of. Initially only came on a six-month basis, and had it deservedly extended. The hope is that history repeats itself, as he is yet another key figure in the squad who proved their worth and then some, appearing in three discrete left-sided roles.
26. Jay O’Shea
Total Games / Total Minutes: 47 / 4,589
Goals Scored: 16
Goals Assisted: 6
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right-sided central midfielder in a three / Left-sided central midfielder in a three / Attacking midfielder in a four
Assessment: Everything I thought he’d be in his first year with the club he turned out to be in his second. Like several others, he was tasked with a different role than he was used to, playing as a right-sided central midfielder rather than off the striker or as an inside forward. The adjustment took time, and given that he forged a reputation as a goalscoring attack-minded player over a creative one, it’s truly astonishing he racked up 16 goals from such a withdrawn position. Even excluding penalties and direct free-kicks, the total would still be in double figures. All of this means he’s the best by that metric at the club in over half a century.
The goals did dry up by the end of February, but his contributions in those five months of white-hot form were extraordinary, earning him multiple Player of the Month awards, nominated for Player of the Season, and even a place in the EFL Overall Team of the Season. Whilst defending is never going to be his strongest suit, he had to do his fair share of tracking back and sitting in to protect leads, intercepting plenty of potentially dangerous passes into his own third.
What Next: Extended his contract on the quiet in January, for all that that’s currently worth. Like Mayor, there’ll be a queue of teams wanting his services, and as much as I’d love him to stay, I can’t realistically conceive of a way in which that will happen.
27. Gold Omotayo
Total Games / Total Minutes: 17 / 617
Goals Scored: 1
Goals Assisted: 0
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left-sided striker in a two / Right-sided striker in a two
Assessment: Along with McFadzean and Jordan Archer, the giant Swiss-Nigerian target man made up one of the trio drafted in from non-league by then Sporting Director Lee Dykes. Initial signs were promising, scoring an injury-time winner on his debut from the bench against a depleted Yeovil Town. Since then, he was given a loan spell at National League side Maidstone Town, notching once during a 35-day arrangement. Eked his way back into contention in March, most often used as a battering ram when chasing the game to divert attention away from Maynard.
What Next: He possesses all the physical attributes to make something from a pro career. Usually in a good position to shoot but rarely able to for one reason or another, I think it’s reasonable to suggest he’ll be elsewhere next season.
31. Neil Danns
Total Games / Total Minutes: 39 / 2,931
Goals Scored: 2
Goals Assisted: 4
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Defensive midfielder in a three / Right-sided central midfielder in a three / Left-sided central midfielder in a three
Assessment: An instrumental presence on and off the pitch, the club captain didn’t have a stellar year in terms of his own form, but that won’t be what fans remember about him. Nominally the most defensive-minded midfielder before the arrival of Rossiter, the 36 year-old wasn’t especially cut out for the task. That said, few could accuse him of lacking the effort needed for such a demanding position. At Moss Rose, he rolled back the years with a brace of highest quality, providing a timely reminder of his talents further forward.
Rossiter’s signing all but relegated him to the bench for the last four months, but he was more than up to the task when coming on, with accurate passes into the channels a staple of his game.
What Next: He wants to continue playing for a couple more years yet, and will have a chance few Guyanese internationals would’ve dreamt possible this summer, being a big influence behind the small country’s qualification for the Gold Cup, their first ever major tournament. A massive motivator behind the scenes, he could be afforded the chance for one final season at Bury.
32. Caolan Lavery
Total Games / Total Minutes: 29 / 1,339
Goals Scored: 6
Goals Assisted: 0
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Right-sided striker in a two
Assessment: An unremarkable capture in many ways, the Sheffield United loanee gave plenty of huff and puff to a forward line that already had that in abundance. In his defence, he rarely had a full 90 minutes to impress, but did manage to get three goals in two derby day clashes with Oldham Athletic, the last of which had huge significance in the context of that fixture. Didn’t face towards the opposition goalkeeper enough for me, which limited the number of shots he was able to get off. A goal every 220 minutes or so doesn’t tell the full story one way or the other. More aggressive in the tackle than his competitors, this was usually at the expense of giving away a free-kick.
What Next: Released by the Blades, there’s still an outside bet that he’ll be back at Gigg Lane, or an ambitious outfit in the fourth tier once more. At 26, he needs to be holding down a regular spot in the EFL.
36. Nicky Maynard
Total Games / Total Minutes: 39 / 3,453
Goals Scored: 22
Goals Assisted: 7
Most Common Position / Role & All Roles: Left-sided striker in a two
Assessment: Curiously overlooked for official recognition of any kind at the end of the season, the much-travelled striker has to rank up there for me as one of the very best to adorn a Bury shirt in my 25 years of watching the club. Bearing in mind he was picked up as a free agent in October, to finish 2018/2019 north of 20 goals in all competitions is an outstanding achievement, and even more so conversely when you take into consideration that they only represented just over a fifth of the Shakers’ tally.
A provider as well as a predator, his all-round game, despite his protestations about being poor at heading, is proof positive of his past, much more lofty history. Scored a plethora of crucial goals, some more beautiful than others. His work-rate, first touch (most of the time), and movement really did make him the missing piece in the jigsaw up front.
What Next: An option already exists to extend his deal. It would be fantastic if that was somehow able to happen, but I have my doubts. A more stable club must surely be ready to take him on, which would follow the pattern of other recent potent strikers having single year stints.
Unused Players – What Next?
8. Stephen Dawson
Almost certain to leave in the summer, the tough-tackling central midfielder has been beset by injury problems and woeful displays when Lowe did pick him in the early going. The highest hurdle to a swift departure is the year remaining on his deal, but with pronouncements of cutting costs at the club, he might be persuaded to take a cut of what remains and move on.
9. Jermaine Beckford
The veteran striker played just 13 minutes in 2018/2019 after an aborted comeback from a lateral cruciate ligament injury. He targetted a return to first team action around the time of the play-offs, which thankfully weren’t required. His contract expires in June, and I’d be gobsmacked if he was still here after then.
14. Phil Edwards
Relegated to featuring in just the EFL Trophy on three occasions, the conservative right-back’s attributes are an ill-fit for an expansive, attack-minded wing-back system, possessing neither the height nor pace to make a decent fist of being one of the wider centre-backs in that formation. Certain to leave on the expiry of his contract in June.
17. Jordan Archer
Used extensively at Southport on loan as a lone target man, he hit nine goals in 31 appearances in all competitions for the National League North outfit. Still has a year to run on his deal at Gigg Lane, and has yet to be seen adorning the white and royal blue in a meaningful fixture. Difficult to envisage that changing after the elevation to the third tier, but he might get the opportunity to impress in pre-season friendlies to alter that perception.
20. Joe Adams
Finished well clear in the U18s top goalscorer charts, despite almost exclusively being used as a wide forward on either flank in a front three. Capped several times for Wales U19s, his stock continues to increase, and he made the most of a rare first team chance in the EFL Trophy with an assist, putting in a hanging cross for Telford of all people to head in. Mayor’s probable departure should open the door to more consolidated gametime, but don’t expect him to be thrust into the XI from the off. Strong with both feet, he’s a different kind of prospect, and one that needs developing in a sensible manner.
23. Joe Skarz
Distinctly unimpressive by all accounts on loan at FC Halifax Town for the entirety of 2018/2019. A mirror image of Edwards but on the left flank; now 29, perhaps his extensive injury history has sadly caught up with his body when he ought to be in his prime. His contract almost certainly won’t be renewed.
24. Tom Aldred
A mainstay for SPFL side Motherwell for the second season running, he’s barely missed a minute of action as the right-sided centre-back in a flat four at Fir Park. Clearly unwanted by Lowe when he perhaps had the chance to make him part of his plans south of the border, I’d be surprised if he didn’t end up once more lining up for the Steelmen in 2019/2020.
28. Saul Shotton
Surprisingly overlooked for minutes for the first team (particularly with the EFL Trophy in mind), given his commendable efforts last season. The young left-footed ball-playing centre back has yet to sign terms offered to him at the close of last season (meaning he’s still a scholar rather than a pro), which will negatively impact any offer from another club for his services from a Bury perspective…
29. Callum Hulme
The second player to receive a lengthy pro deal, the key for him is to improve his discipline. There’s little question he has the talent to make a success of a pro career – I haven’t seen that many youngsters have the range of passing he possesses, and he can also be effective anywhere in central midfield. What takes the gloss off slightly are a small number of very questionable incidents resulting in red cards. I wouldn’t be altogether surprised if an offer came in for him during the summer, but I’d be more than happy to be witness to a calmer, more focused individual donning a first team shirt with more regularity next season.
33. Harry Bunn
Spent almost the whole term on loan at higher tier Southend United, where he had a mixed bag of a season, full of the usual struggles to stay off the treatment table and flashes of quality. Started off for the Shrimpers mainly as an inside forward cutting in from the left of a 4-4-2 or 4-2-3-1, before latterly being partnered up top with Simon Cox. Two crucial goals during League One’s crazy relegation run-in were worth four points to his temporary side, making a huge difference to their hopes of survival in the process. Is there a chance for him to be back at Bury in the final year of his deal? I think it’s very slim, personally, even in the event of Mayor leaving. I envisage a similar situation to the one facing Dawson in the early weeks of the close season.
35. Scott Burgess
Another unfancied by Lowe, he had two loan spells in the upper echelons of the non-league system; the first was cut short at Wrexham with minutes on the pitch severely limited by the form of others in central midfield, and the second was with York City a tier below the Red Dragons, being a key part of a squad that pulled the Minstermen away from choppy waters and an unthinkable relegation into step three. Reportedly offered a permanent stay by manager Steve Watson, he could be plying his trade at the new stadium at some point next season.
37. Dougie Nyaupembe
Has the pace and flexibility to work in Lowe’s preferred style, but two loan spells at local sides Hyde United and Stalybridge Celtic respectively suggest that his future could lie away from BL9. Regular minutes at Bower Fold would’ve done him the world of good; turning 20 later his year, this is a career-defining summer for the Zimbabwean youngster. Yet again, it probably won’t be with Bury.
38. Sam Allardyce
The grandson of the one-time England boss, he’s perhaps a victim of there being no U23s setup more than he is any shortcomings in his game in being released at the end of his scholarship. Admittedly more effective as a centre-back without the ball than with (although he has worked hard to improve that aspect), he’ll almost certainly resurface at a club that can financially accommodate taking low-risk signings in bulk in the hopes of one or two of them eventually progressing to their first team or being sold on at a handsome profit.
39. Aaron Skinner
Developed as a full-back through the academy but was deployed frequently in central midfield, most notably during the FA Cup Youth run to the quarter-finals. Has had experience of being the captain for the U18s, and will be a key figure for Ryan Kidd in 2019/2020.
40. Aaron Brown
More goals will be expected from the Northern Irish forward during the second year of his scholarship, hitting just four in 2018/2019. He can play as the focal point or on the left of a front three (a favourite ploy of Kidd’s), and will have to contend with the likes of Joe Collins, Bright Amoateng, Cedric Ondoa and Femi Seriki (more on him below) for opportunities next season. Some players thrive on the increased competition, so let’s hope he’s one of those.
41. Cameron Hill
Much like Allardyce, he’ll probably have the same fate after his release. Started off the campaign on fire with the U18s, belying his withdrawn playmaker role in midfield to get amongst the goals. A bad injury kept him out for four or five months, before coming back in time for the Liverpool clash. He perhaps wonder what might’ve been without that setback.
42. Femi Seriki
Graced the bench on final day against Port Vale. The main purpose behind that was to push his name into the shop window again. Having only turned 16 a fortnight ago, he can play anywhere down the right side of the pitch or in a two up front. Crashed in an impressive eight goals from out wide whilst still underage for the U18s in 2018/2019. Still very rough around the edges, retaining him for the duration of his scholarship will prove difficult.
43. Scott Moloney
Impressed Lowe enough in training that he was content to have the young custodian on the bench after Preston North End loanee Mathew Hudson’s deal expired, rather than source a replacement. Suspect he’ll have to make do with the same next season, regardless of whether Murphy is still at Gigg Lane, but could be thrown into the EFL Trophy group games if the format remains close to the last few years.
It’s frankly impossible to carry on in the same vein as the previous analyses this campaign to conclude 2018/2019. Well-documented off-field issues on here and elsewhere did spill over to matches themselves. Without taking anything away from the sides that beat Bury during April, it’s difficult not to wonder whether some of those might have been prevented had the players been paid, and had manager Ryan Lowe not gone above and beyond his remit to motivate non-football staff, as well as a downbeat squad.
Fortunately, a mixture of an unbelievable rekindling of the team spirit, fans and club being as one (with the usual caveat), and promotion rivals Mansfield Town and Milton Keynes’ equally woeful form ensured the Shakers made it over the threshold with a game to spare. Requiring a point from a daunting looking trip to Prenton Park, Lowe’s heroes rallied from a relatively poor first half display by their standards to deservedly equalise in the second period, restricting the division’s top goalscorer James Norwood much more successfully than had been the case in the early exchanges. The enforced substitution of Eoghan O’Connell for Will Aimson after 38 minutes proved to be the catalyst to regain a foothold in the contest.
It was perhaps poetic that Danny Mayor was the one to get the all-important leveller. Just like with Tom Soares’ effort four years prior on the same ground, the actual finish wasn’t pretty, being hit against a defender’s leg, but you’d be hard-pressed to find someone who cared at that very moment or in the days since. Besides which, his turn on the halfway line to create the opening all by himself was a bittersweet reminder of his peerless ability to conjure something out of nothing, and that it will likely not be seen in white and royal blue again.
Rightly, the euphoria and imbibing of several shandies by everyone involved at the club once promotion was confirmed lasted well into the week. Although the final fixture at home to Port Vale was largely academic, a second 1-1 draw in the space of five days had two rare moments: firstly, sections of the home support applauding an opposition goal; Tom Pope took to Twitter after the match to acknowledge that:
Congratulations @buryfcofficial on the promotion and thank you to the fans for a lovely reception considering I didn’t give you the best of me you still gave me an incredible reception for which I’m truly grateful! Hopefully I’ll see you in a couple of years 👍🏻👍🏻
Secondly, Jordan Rossiter, rarely seen in deep in enemy territory, was left completely unmarked outside the area to arc a beautiful left-footed shot into the far corner. In a career dogged by injury, that goal marked only his third in senior football. Having come through his loan spell constituting 16 games unscathed and his reputation enhanced, Glasgow Rangers boss Steven Gerrard will doubtlessly be ecstatic that the gamble worked.
The result meant Bury clung on to runners-up spot behind champions Lincoln City, six points off the Imps and with a superior goal difference to MK. Suffice it to say, whilst on paper, the grand total of 22 wins and 79 points is nothing special (and is indeed ‘worse’ than previous successful campaigns), the circumstances in which the last 10 or so games were played out under makes it the most remarkable of the 11 promotions in the club’s 125 years in the EFL. It’s also reasonable to suggest that many followers of other teams are far from happy about the nature of it, which isn’t going to go away anytime soon. I’ll make an attempt to address this at the end of this post.
Ben Mayhew’s xG timelines illustrate that there was very little to choose between the Shakers and their opponents, almost without exception:
Ryan Kidd’s side wrapped up their highly commendable season with a derby defeat to a very strong Rochdale outfit, which meant they finished just outside the top three. Nevertheless, the greatest success of the term was in the FA Youth Cup, reaching the quarter-final stage against all odds before being understandably outclassed by Liverpool.
The likes of Joe Adams, Callum Hulme, and the well-regarded Femi Seriki were on all the bench for the senior setup on Saturday. Whether by accident or design, it’s hard to envisage these instances not increasing in League One; the budget will almost certainly be cut much further than what happened last summer (if the club survive the winding-up petition). That should also entail a smaller roster and perhaps a little less reluctance on the part of Lowe (should he stay) to give some of the more promising talents meaningful gametime.
As you can see from the Twitter thread above, the academy are still proceeding as normal for next season. The Carrington training complex, divisive among Bury fans as it is, remains a vitally important component of the underage structure, and that should not be dismissed out of hand so readily if the club are to really cut their cloth. The Shakers could do a lot worse than attempt to emulate the likes of Crewe Alexandra if they want to remain a beacon to players released from higher category institutions, as well as developing their own in-house for a fairly streamlined pathway at present to at least the fringes of the first team.
It would be extremely remiss not to mention at the huge success achieved throughout the different women’s sides.
In his first season with the U18s, Chris Honor led his charges to two cup finals and a top-three finish in their division.
The reserves managed to best higher tier opposition in the form of Nelson on on penalties during their Lancashire FA Plate Final encounter after mounting a thrilling comeback in regular time. Kimberly Tyson was particularly impressive up top, showing calmness under pressure for a cool finish for the second goal in the highlights package below:
Colin Platt’s team also came third in their pool, and they will hoping for an even better term next season.
The senior side under the auspices of Scott Johnson have gone from strength to strength ever since he was handed the reins just weeks after the campaign got underway, culminating in a title win and promotion at Gigg Lane itself on Sunday. For club stalwarts like captain Lucy Golding and Aymee Openshaw, the trophy has been a long time in the making, and it will be intriguing to see how they cut their teeth in the North West Premier Division, the fifth tier of the women’s pyramid. A very young squad overall, the potential is most certainly present for them to push higher in the next few years. It’s something I’ll be paying even closer attention to on this blog and when my podcast launches later this summer…
Whilst the celebrations of the past week were taking place, there was of course a very notable person in absentia. Owner Steve Dale has not been seen at the club recently, and his last set of ramblings on the official site dated the 25th of April made stark the grave situation facing the club, even if like me, you don’t take all the figures and needless anecdotes mentioned at face value.
At the time of writing, there are just eight days to go until the adjourned High Court appearance. Director Matt McCarthy mentioned in a more recent local radio interview that there are some interested parties looking to purchase the club from Dale. Simultaneously, there’s a new initiative that’s launched called ‘Buy Our Bury’. They’re looking for pledges from supporters with the aim of making the BL9 outfit fan-owned.
Correctly in my view, they’re not assuming that any successful takeover from Dale will transpire. Even if one does, I firmly believe it’s in the interests of any would-be party to have a conversation with BOB to help spread the financial burden of operating a full-time professional team in the domestic game. If you can, I’d like you to pledge an amount to the campaign. If not, please share the website with your friends. It might make all the difference.
Is this it?
I’d like to take this opportunity to address anyone who’s read up to this point and feels that the men’s team have ‘cheated’ their way to promotion: You’re half-right… but the culpability rests mainly with people no longer at the club – Stewart Day and Lee Clark. The vast majority of the alleged higher earners on the books have barely been used, if at all, by Ryan Lowe during 2018/2019 for various reasons. Does that assuage the overspending by the club for years? Not in the least.
All clubs in the Championship, 2/3 in the Premier League are losing money. Oxford announced their results this morning & had £4m trading loss. Championship income £530m & Wage bill £590m is the problem pic.twitter.com/sqQoUzLFf4
Should there be a punishment for clubs like Bury that have continued to spend beyond their means? Yes, I think so. However, we have seen all too keenly and all too frequently as of late that the EFL are not fit for purpose, and there’s nothing in their current rules and regulations to combat this. Every side in the Championship during 2017/2018 made a loss, in spite of the far higher level of income being part of the second tier ensures. That pattern is largely repeated in the lower reaches, especially when you take out money made from player sales. Again, that in no way excuses the reckless behaviour in the Gigg Lane boardroom during the past six years.
There is the chance that the new owners will wipe out the debt owed to all the creditors, and whilst in many senses that would constitute the best possible outcome for everyone, it could easily be seen as a ‘cheat code’ that draws a definitive line under the past with no repercussions whatsoever. I have a lot of sympathy with that argument, but until there comes a time that one or more high profile club goes bust, I just can’t foresee the EFL doing anything meaningful to clamp down on rogue owners and a flagrant disregard for the long-term futures of clubs. Financial Fair Play (FFP) hasn’t had the desired effect, and is not enforced in the same way throughout the divisions. You only have to glance at how they have handled the even bigger shambles due west at Bolton Wanderers to glean an understanding that massive financial reform is well overdue… but is the collective appetite there for it? What’s next on the blog?
Regardless of the outcome of the High Court case, I’ll be doing a detailed analysis on every player used in the second half of the season; discussing the retained list (if it’s released in the conventional sense…); putting together my alternative take on League Two Team of the Season; detailing my night at the Football Blogging Awards, which takes place this Thursday at the Etihad Stadium in Manchester; lastly, I hope to have at least one Q&A in the pipeline… and that’s far as I can look with the club’s future still up in the air.
Tightening Up… at Both Ends (aka Scott Wharton’s Impact and Easing the Burden on Nicky Maynard)
There can be no question now that the pressure is for the first time this season on Ryan Lowe’s men to ensure that the deserved 3-1 home reverse against Swindon Town last weekend does not come to signify anything more than a defeat in a highly competitive division.
Prior to the encounter, Bury had experienced an uncharacteristic spell of clean sheets, most typified by the emerging importance of Blackburn Rovers loanee Scott Wharton on the left side of the centre back three. The 21 year-old has largely been an assured presence in a previously weaker area of the XI, winning a greater proportion of aerial challenges and being more accurate (and shorter) with his passing than was expected of him under Danny Cowley at likely league champions Lincoln City.
No single shape in football is infallible, and the attacking thrust firmly emphasised by Lowe will almost always ensure the opposition in any given match have opportunities to give tough examinations of Wharton and his partners on the counter. When teams like the Robins push up their wingers to the same level as the nominally lone striker, it can often leave the defence in a three-on-three mini-game of sorts, and they can’t win every single one of those battles, especially when the frequency of those situations is as high as what was witnessed on Saturday.
On the flip side of the general tightening up at the back, at the other end, neither the goals nor quite the free-flowing movement was demonstrated in March; Macclesfield Town aside, the Shakers could only muster three more strikes in the month. You’d perhaps expect it to decrease at least a little as the scramble for points necessitates a more conservative posture from sides they play against, but it can’t have also escaped people’s attention that besides Wharton’s own commendable couple of efforts and a Jay O’Shea penalty, no-one else troubled the score-sheet except Nicky Maynard, who continues to gamely fight for second place in League Two’s top goalscorer charts with Kieran Agard and Tyler Walker of promotion rivals Milton Keynes Dons and Mansfield Town respectively.
Ordinarily, this wouldn’t be that big of a problem. Most clubs are reliant on one or two players to regularly get the goals to help them achieve their aims, but that just hasn’t been the case in 2018/2019, and the onus is really now on others to step up to assist Maynard. Caolan Lavery’s form has taken a nosedive since the derby with Oldham Athletic; Byron Moore might now be needed elsewhere (thanks to Danny Mayor); Dom Telford pulled up in the warm-up before the game at Grimsby Town; lastly, Gold Omotayo’s recent cameos from the bench have unfortunately not done much to inspire confidence.
Mayor’s three game suspension, which I’ll discuss at length further into this article, also means some of the trickery will inevitably be lost from the starting lineup, so more of the chances might need to be created between the striking partnership themselves, which has frequently rotated alongside Maynard.
Ben Mayhew’s xG timelines ably demonstrate a distinct drop-off in the Shakers’ supremacy during a month where the performances were less than sparkling:
Neil Danns’ Gold Cup qualification
Looking away from Gigg Lane for a moment, I thought it was certainly worth mentioning captain Neil Danns’ exploits for Guyana during the international break. A win for the Golden Jaguars over Belize in the final CONCACAF Nations League fixture ensured their participation at this summer’s Gold Cup, the first major tournament in the country’s history. Danns scored one spot kick and missed another, but there was no question that he massively contributed to their success under the guidance of Michael Johnson, the former Birmingham City and Derby County centre-back.
At 36 and with his contract up in the summer, there are inevitably question marks as to whether Danns will go into that tournament still a Bury player, but either way, I’ll be keeping a close eye on the action, which kicks off on the 15th of June. The draw will be held in Los Angeles in nine days’ time.
‘Replacing’ Danny Mayor for three games
Back to matters closer to home. There can be little doubt that at 2-1 down to Swindon, the Shakers still had a decent chance of restoring parity, despite being largely second best throughout the match. That task was made mightily more difficult by an idiotic lashing out by Mayor in response to a very poor challenge (to say the least) by Canice Carroll. No-one, and I include myself in this, is expecting a professional footballer to stay cool 100% of the time, especially when you’re fouled as often as the inside forward is. The stats have him in the top 10 in the fourth tier for fouls suffered, and then of course are the instances where he still gets kicked and nothing is given by the referee, which happens most often to the most dangerous players.
I have seen some people on social media suggest he and others like him should be offered more ‘protection’ by the match official. In practice, how would that actually manifest itself? Are they supposed to identify the ‘danger men’ before the game kicks off, and give the offender a red card regardless? No, there must be objectivity. Anyone that persistently targets and subsequently fouls an individual will eventually be sent off. If it’s a ‘team effort’, then in one sense, it shows just how much of a threat Mayor poses to them, and there has to be an acceptance on some level that that’s how it’s going to be.
The rush of blood to his head was thankfully not defended too strongly by Lowe in the post-match interview, who privately must have been incandescent about the incident. A good manager recognises that there are different personalities within a squad; Mayor is the epitome of an introvert off the field who, once he graces the turf, usually feels confident to express himself with some sublime pieces of skill and to beat his man repeatedly on the dribble.
His self-imposed absence comes at the most crucial juncture of the entire campaign, and provides Lowe with a huge tactical quandary in the next two weeks. There is no obvious candidate to replicate what Mayor brings… because they just don’t exist. That’s not a disparagement of anyone else on the roster, merely a reflection of the current predicament.
As a consequence, I decided to pose the question to fellow supporters on Twitter:
So… Danny Mayor will be suspended for three matches. Who do you put in his place? #buryfc
The versatile 30 year-old possesses the positional know-how and pace to bypass his marker and cut inside on his stronger right foot. As teams sit ever deeper during the run-in and hit Bury on the break, which Cambridge United are bound to do tomorrow evening (and I don’t blame them), Lowe is going to require someone to reliably carry the ball forward into the final third to both minimise the chances of that occurring, and to try to get in behind resolute backlines.
Moore has already proven to be a capable option in the left channel, and his presence would ensure that the transition to attack can still take place without having to resort to more direct methods, or pushing up others too high. It is the closest role he will receive under the 5-2-1-2 to his most natural place on the wing, and he is highly accurate when crossing the ball, drilling it into the box or shifting onto his right for a deeper far post effort.
The case against:
The aforementioned form of strikers not called Nicky Maynard. Moore, who has a one goal every four games on average during 2018/2019, has been adept up top, operating wider than most forwards would in a conventional pairing. With Telford possibly still out for a little while yet, his services might best be utilised alongside Maynard, rather than being tasked with supplying him.
His instincts are firmly on the attacking end of the spectrum, which is a double-edged sword in a system designed to take the game to the opposition in numbers. Will he really sit back to allow Callum McFadzean to hurtle up the flank on the outside, rather than drift inside? The conclusion I draw is that he’s much better when focused as high up the pitch as possible, and in a side already lacking ball-winners, he is even less defensively-minded than the man he’d be replacing.
The case for:
The skipper’s (temporary) restoration to the XI would ensure a true three-man midfield. Even before Mayor’s dismissal, it was plain to see that Rossiter was doing all the leg-work in the middle, which the more adventurous sides in the final seven games could easily exploit if afforded the opportunity to do so. It would also allow O’Shea to concentrate more on late runs to the edge of the area, and less on having to help out the Glasgow Rangers loanee (or less often, anyway). Danns is by no means a ball-winning midfielder, but you can guarantee his maximum effort to cover as much ground between the two boxes as possible.
It would also give more balance to the midfield, which would go hand in hand with a greater degree of flexibility. There might yet be situations in the three games ahead where Bury need to hold onto a lead, and I’d sooner trust Danns to hold fort than the other candidates discussed in this section.
The case against:
You’d be asking an awful lot of the wing-backs, both to provide the width and the attacking thrust.. McFadzean would more or less have to go it alone down the left flank, with the most attack-minded of the midfielders usually operating closer to Nicky Adams. The vice-captain, for his part, has not enjoyed the best time of it in recent games, but to expect totally consistent displays from individuals who are ultimately plying their trade in the fourth tier is a misguided one.
Would there be enough guile and creativity in the lineup? As much as I love O’Shea, he’s what I’d categorise as a goalscoring attacking midfielder, rather than as a playmaker. As I’ve already mentioned, it’s likely that it will be a case of having to break down two banks of four/five. Without someone to carry the ball from deep and do the unexpected, there’s an air of predictability in the approach play.
The case for:
Regular readers of this blog will know I mention Joe Adams from time-to-time, and for good reason. Rewarded for his displays in the youth side with a pro deal until June 2021 (currently the longest contract of anyone at Bury at the time of writing), he could just be the option few opposition scouts would anticipate playing. Lowe has often spoken with praise for him, whilst understandably being cautious about throwing him at the deep end. Still only 18, the Welsh U19 international is top scorer for Ryan Kidd’s youngsters this season, bagging 13 goals without ever playing in a conventional striker’s role.
He has the pace and the dribbling ability to beat his man and get in behind, but equally as importantly, he is strong with both feet from crossing situations, meaning that as his marker, you don’t know for sure which way he’ll go, and the Shakers could really do with that level of uncertainty in the opposition ranks without Mayor.
The case against:
As much as the manager is an advocate of developing talent, it would constitute a huge risk to thrust him into the starting lineup at his age, and in the situation the club find themselves in. Like Moore, his positivity could easily lead to counterattacks, and there’s also the small matter of whether he’s still injured, having had to drop out of the last Welsh squad he was called up for a fortnight ago. Like Telford, you don’t tend to get estimated return dates from Lowe during interviews, perhaps in an effort to keep his next opponents guessing.
Even if fit, there’s a time to properly ‘blood’ academy graduates, and it differs on a case-by-case basis. He might have a much bigger role next season in what is likely to be a squad reduced in numbers by a smaller playing budget (regardless of division) and the continuing lack of an U23s setup.
The unbeaten run, and ‘negative’ predictions
As the title of this post states, nothing lasts forever, which is especially true in football. The recency effect of less than scintillating displays, coupled with the defeat, has led to the return of negativity, and in greater amounts than I’d have expected. To go 14 matches without leaving a ground pointless is a superb achievement in any league, and the circumstances behind the remarkable turn-around in fortunes under Lowe.
In my preview of the game for Steven Fyfe’s blog for Saturday, I said Bury would lose to Swindon… and so they did. I caught quite a bit of flack for prognosticating ‘doom’, even being asked after the event whether I was happy that my prediction was correct! The answer to that should be blatantly obvious – no. However, I’m not going to do what I see supporters of almost every club do and say they’ll win if I don’t believe it will happen. I knew the threats that Richie Wellens’ outfit had at their disposal, I knew how he’d got them playing a more progressive style of football, and any guess at a result is just that – a guess.
I also play for fun a Predictions Game over on FL2 Blogger, and over the course of the campaign, excluding the rearranged game with Cambridge tomorrow, I have had Bury winning 18, drawing 15, and losing just six of the 39 games, which would leave the Shakers just two points shy of reality. So much for my negative predictions…
The remaining seven fixtures, and the big-game experience in the core squad
Attention now turns to the run-in, with that loss allowing MK to leapfrog Bury into second place. Wins for Mansfield and a white-hot Tranmere Rovers side, themselves with a game in hand on the rest of the pack, has ramped up the stakes for tomorrow evening. It should also be mentioned at this point that I did a bit of research into the ‘big games’ members of the Shakers’ core squad have been in during their careers, and one of the possible advantages of having an older than average dressing room is that there is a wealth of experience of successes (and failures) in promotion tilts through both the automatic and play-off routes, with three-quarters of the 20 used players this calendar year having had at least some memory to fall back on before 2018/2019.
I also decided to poll fans as to how many points they think will be accrued in the remaining seven matches:
The top end of that bracket would be sufficient for a club record points total of 86, beating out 2014/2015’s vintage under a certain David Flitcroft by one. But it won’t be easy to emulate.
Firstly, Colin Calderwood will be hoping for a big reaction of his own from a lacklustre display by the U’s in their own backyard, succumbing to a last-gasp defeat in injury time to top seven hopefuls Colchester United. Their own status in the EFL is still under jeopardy, with Notts County’s big win at the weekend cutting the gap to six points. The visitors have pace on the counter, principally in the guise of Jevani Brown, as well as the tall presence of target man Jabo Ibehre, who, whilst far from prolific this campaign, is exactly the sort of player Bury have struggled to contain.
Carlisle United are in no sort of form, and now find themselves outside the reckoning by three points. Well beaten by Tranmere, they will nevertheless target a win at Brunton Park this coming Saturday. Jamie Devitt is one of the best players in League Two, and you wouldn’t put it past Hallam Hope adding to his considerable goal tally against his former side.
The aforementioned Colchester come to BL9 on the 13th, and will probably be within a victory of the top seven at worst by the time the crunch fixture rolls around. The other U’s are the most puzzling outfit in the league, equally as capable of doling out thrashings as they are at receiving them. They should set their stall out to attack more than most have at Gigg Lane this season, with pace to burn on the wings and one of the best central midfield partnerships in the division – Sammie Szmodics in particular could cause damage.
Rodney Parade is a tough place to travel to, and Bury can expect little benevolence from Newport County on Good Friday. With 11 wins and just three losses at home, Michael Flynn’s charges are also still eyeing a late play-off surge, with two games in hand in which to reduce arrears. Jamille Matt had the beating of Adam Thompson in the reverse fixture, and both Padraig Amond and Ade Azeez are good options to call on if the Jamaican needs more support up top.
Easter Monday will pit the Shakers against probably the only side in their remaining games with ostensibly nothing to play for. Northampton Town have enjoyed some improvement under Keith Curle, but nothing too dramatic to convince observers that they’ll be challenging at the top end in 2019/2020. Nonetheless, they showed their defensive mettle in the earlier stalemate, and have some canny operators in midfield to ensure anything but smooth sailing.
For me, the key aim remains avoiding needing to go to Prenton Park on the penultimate weekend needing a result to seal promotion. Tranmere’s winning streak is no fluke, and whilst I think it’s almost certain that it will be snapped before the last game in April, they still look ominous at the moment, and I see little reason why their performances will taper off. Resolute in goal and at the back, unassailable top scorer James Norwood is backed up by a supporting cast in similar rich veins of form – the likes of Ollie Banks and Connor Jennings must be shut down to get anything from the game.
Port Vale ought to be all but home and dry on final day, but veteran Tom Pope will want to add to his century of goals (and counting) for the Burslem outfit. There is major concern off the pitch, but I don’t think it will prove the distraction some would like to believe on it. Again, Bury really don’t want to go into needing the points to cement a place in the top three…
Double glory for the women’s sides?
Scott Johnson’s side are now firm favourites to win the championship and with it, the only promotion place available. A 13-0 shellacking of Morecambe Reserves yesterday underlined the quality throughout the team and on the bench. Four wins from the remaining five will guarantee 2019/2020 in the North West Premier Division, and the same number of games will take place in double headers against Cammell Laird 1907 and Preston North End, each instance being inexplicably played after the first game, with only an hour break…
The very wet weather in the middle of the month caused the Reserves’ Plate Final against Nelson at Leyland to be postponed until this coming Sunday. Defeat to Stanwix Juniors put paid to Colin Platt’s slim hopes of promotion, but he will be hoping that strikers Sarah Knight and Kimberley Tyson can upset their higher tier opponents, and bring some silverware back home for a positive end to a very encouraging season under his leadership.
There are now just 10 matches left of the regular League Two season. Ryan Lowe and his Bury charges must watch all three of their main rivals for automatic promotion play this Tuesday evening, and he will be hoping for an unexpected slip-up from at least one of the contenders. In this blogpost, I take a deep dive into how each side has risen to the highest echelons of the fourth tier, the strengths and weaknesses of their current tactics, and crucially, predict which one will miss have to settle for the crapshoot of the play-offs.
Last weekend’s fixtures didn’t turn out quite how I’d anticipated, with Milton Keynes Dons swapping positions with Mansfield Town in the table as a consequence. Lincoln City remain very much in pole position, with a game in a hand on nearest rivals Bury, and an eight point cushion over fourth, coupled with a slightly superior goal difference. The Shakers sit out Tuesday evening’s gameweek because of the Cheltenham Festival, having had that clash brought forward a week. They will privately be hoping for another slip-up from one of their rivals, even though manager Ryan Lowe would be loath to admit that publicly. Unexpected outcomes are bound to occur during the run-in, which is the focus of the next section.
Historical Performance of Fourth Tier Teams in Last 10 Matches
To view the images in a higher resolution, open in a new tab/window, remove the text after ‘.png’ and press enter – Peter Løhmann’s charts are a labour of love and they offer superb insight into patterns and trends from the last 20 seasons in the fourth tier:
There are caveats to using past data to inform any future predictions, naturally. The general conclusion however is to expect the unexpected in small doses. For example, not once have the teams occupying 1st and 2nd after 36 matches have taken place subsequently fallen out of the automatic places in the last 20 years. Similarly, never has the outfit in 3rd bombed out of the top seven altogether, and the current makeup of this campaign’s table makes that even harder to envisage happening. It’s something almost completely mirrored by the club in 4th, with one exception – 12th in 2009/2010! Even if the Stags somehow didn’t win another game from hereon in, I don’t think they’d plumb such depths. The majority of their remaining games are with sides whose league status is all but assured either way, as the matrix below illustrates:
In order to have a more informed view, I’ve looked at how each of the managers at the helm for the contenders have set up tactically, form over the previous 10 games in League Two, scrutinising their next 10 (nine in Bury’s case), and finally, the thankless task of predicting just how it will all finish, starting with…
Most common recent XI, shape, and strategy
‘Common wisdom’ would have you believe that Danny Cowley sets his side up in a very direct style, full of tall, hard-working cloggers, whose main aim is to dish out reducers and nick a goal from a set piece or John Akinde penalty. It’s not a perception I concur with at all. Admittedly, they’re not normally as easy on the eye as the other promotion contenders, but neither he nor their burgeoning fanbase will care one jot about that. The most crucial metric, after all, is their points tally.
Stylistically, they almost always have a flat back-four. Veteran goalkeeper Matt Gilks, a January deadline day capture, has been an assured presence between the sticks, and has boxed off probably the only area of mild weakness in the side. He is protected by the best central defensive duo in the division bar none. Imperious stand-in captain Jason Shackell did pick up an injury in their last match under the lights at Sincil Bank, and the Cowley patented ‘Fog of War’ will be in effect as to an accurate date for his expected return. The stopper is utterly dominant in the air, winning more than two thirds of his duels; naturally, this has translated to a decent haul of goals, too. Having Cian Bolger as your replacement speaks volumes about the quality on the roster.
Michael Bostwick has filled in as an anchor man in a double pivot during the season, but is most at home in the heart of defence. Much like Shackell, he laps up high balls and floated crosses all match long, but is also a decent passer of the ball. The key to the setup is the width provided down the flanks, and the balance struck by Harry Toffolo and Neal Eardley so as not to expose their teammates too frequently. Both of them will push high up the pitch, and have usually plenty of targets in and around the penalty area to aim for. Toffolo is probably the more dynamic of the two, but it would be remiss not to highlight Eardley’s importance to the side, especially in holding the shape of the defence without the ball – it’s often in that phase where the level of the coaching the players have received is most evident.
Skipper Lee Frecklington’s enforced absence has left a place up for grabs in midfield alongside the experienced Michael O’Connor, who is apt to sit in the central third more often than not to ensure the numbers are rarely not in Lincoln’s favour if countered upon. He breaks up play with a strong ground game, and looks to spread the ball out wide when an option is available. Mark O’Hara has started the last two fixtures, and underlined his claim with the winner against Yeovil Town, showing off his good movement and powerful heading ability for his goal. He has the speed and stamina to maintain a high level of performance throughout the 90 minutes, as well as the utility to be repositioned if the need arises without adversely affecting what he can offer, and to work alongside O’Connor to close out matches.
The wingers have the licence to join in the attacks at will, so they often appear to be in a three or four-man forward line when taking the game to the opposition. Bruno Andrade had a superb February, winning Player of the Month and weighing in with a remarkable six goals in four fixtures. One of the most exciting individuals to watch in this season’s fourth tier, his strength lies in beating his man and pulling off the spectacular to create a chance or shooting opportunity, usually leaving crossing duties to the overlapping Toffolo.
On the right, Harry Anderson has Akinde at the far post to try to pick out, which goes some way to explaining his greater number of attempts at getting the ball to him from out wide. His pace aids his side greatly in getting to the final third and making the opposition think twice about committing too many men forward of their own. He can also drift into the channel to shoot from range, and has the positional discipline to be part of an attacking midfield trio, where the demands are slightly different.
Akinde is not a classic target man – let’s make that clear. Yes, he’s handy in the air; yes, he can lay off the ball in the box for a teammate to finish… but it’s the reintroduction of fan favourite Matt Rhead to the XI that has helped to bisect the attention that’s normally all on the former Barnet hitman, and demonstrate once more his proficiency in front of goal, and is very composed on the ball and under pressure. Rhead is unlikely to complete many matches between now and the end of the season, but he does offer a natural focal point for dead ball situations and a viable option for Cowley to select in tight away matches. Shay McCartan and Danny Rowe can also play off Akinde, and use their pace to get in behind the defence when played through.
Form over last 10 league matches
Enjoying a long run without losing, a Toffolo goal was enough to separate The Imps from rivals Grimsby Town in a testy derby encounter. A Rowe brace was sufficient to see off a listing Yeovil Town at Huish Park in a routine away win; if anything, Lincoln have been even better on the road than on their own turf. Another way of framing their six-goal thriller with Bury is that they weren’t ever behind at any stage of the pulsating clash, keeping their rivals at arm’s length in the process.
A (briefly) rejuvenated Notts County held them to a 1-1 draw, which saw a rare penalty miss from Akinde. Further points were dropped in their next two games – a costly sending off for Anderson in the first half let Northampton Town back into the match, and then an Ilias Chair-inspired Stevenage almost stole all three at the death, with Boro roaring back from two down to claim a share of the spoils.
The winless streak was snapped with Bruno Andrade’s double salvo away to Morecambe, which was sandwiched by yet another draw – on that occasion, it was The Imps’ turn to snatch something at the death (the sixth minute of injury time, to be precise) against Exeter City. The last two games at the time of writing have both been more comfortable than the scorelines suggest – although they had to do it the hard way at Forest Green Rovers, they seldom looked in danger of surrendering their lead once they poked their noses in front. The return fixture with the Glovers was little different in that regard.
Remaining fixtures in more detail
Paul Scholes’ Oldham Athletic™ are first up. The Imps ought to take full advantage of an outfit very much still in a transitional phase, and their wide players ought to be afforded space to work in than with most other opponents during the run-in. It’s then pivotal to avoid defeat against Mansfield Town – as clichéd as it doubtlessly comes across, draws at this juncture against near(ish) rivals are nearly as good as wins – anything that maintains the gap to fourth and below is to be welcomed, but they will need to vastly improve their showing from the first clash the sides had in 2018/2019. The Stags remain extremely tricky opponents away from home.
Gabriele Cioffi will be hoping for a similar result to what his Crawley Town side achieved at Bury in February when the Red Devils entertain Lincoln – they are a good match for the Imps physically, but don’t offer too much else. That fixture is then followed up with another game they should obtain three points from ‘on paper’ – Macclesfield Town battle gamely, but they have been found badly wanting at the stage of the season they need to improve, given they are mired in the relegation zone, six points from safety.
It won’t get much bigger than facing Milton Keynes Dons in Buckinghamshire. Just like with Mansfield, the primary objective should be obtaining a draw. A loss would be damaging to their title credentials, and open the door for a possible three-way struggle for supremacy. Mike Duff has improved Cheltenham Town no end since taking over early in the season; however, they remain relatively poor travellers, and will seek to soak up the pressure Lincoln’s forward line can exert on them, especially since The Robins lack the pace (if not the guile) to penetrate the Imps’ steadfast backline.
Few teams relish the trip to Cumbria at the best of times, and it’s likely Carlisle United will still be fighting for one of the lower play-off places on Good Friday. Equally, the Cowleys might target the Easter fixtures to seal promotion, so it ought to be an intriguing encounter. Tranmere Rovers ought to be firmly entrenched in the top seven by then, and any outfit containing James Norwood and two uncompromising centre backs in the form of Manny Monthe and Mark Ellis is almost guaranteed to push the men in red, white, and black all the way.
The remaining two fixtures are away to Newport County, yet another team with the emphasis firmly placed on the physical over the technical. In theory, they should have nothing to play for by then, but even in cases like that, there’s always the chance that a few individuals are still looking to impress Mike Flynn enough to secure contracts for next season. The schizophrenic Colchester United are the final opposition; on their day, they have the quality to beat the top sides, and could be looking to secure their own play-off place. Lincoln definitely don’t want to be going into the game needing something out of it to achieve their main objective.
Analysis & Prediction
Playing Mansfield and MK in the space of four gameweeks will go a long way to determining whether the celebrations in that corner of the East Midlands are raucous or ‘just’ joyous. Losing one or both of those games will put their title hopes in serious jeopardy… but does it matter all that much? Yes, coming first and lifting the League Two trophy has its merits above simply being promoted – no-one would argue against that, and perhaps having led the division for so long, finishing 2nd or 3rd would be disappointing to a degree. I don’t think it will come to that.
Danny Cowley added depth in key areas to a good-sized squad, recruiting sensibly in January. They have the know-how throughout the side to see games out, and the pace in wide positions to land sucker punches on opponents who set their stall out to attack the Imps. Under his very savvy management, they have quietly gone about their business (as quiet as you can having led for so long), racking up the goals without necessarily battering the other team in the margin of victory. The other three sides in this list have all earned plaudits for their style of play at one time or another in 2018/2019, and that might just suit them down the ground.
When they have tasted defeat on the very odd occasion, they’ve always followed it up with a win. Another 18 points should ensure the championship, but I expect it to be much closer than it is now. 1st
Most common recent XI, shape, and strategy
Barely deviating from a blueprint tweaked in the third league match of the campaign, Ryan Lowe has made more than good on his promise when he got the gig permanently of playing an attacking, entertaining style of football, something which can sometimes resemble having seven offensive-minded outfielders to just three defensive ones.
The basic premise is for the centre back trio to all be able to reliably pass out from their third to different targets – their nearest wing-back, Glasgow Rangers regista Jordan Rossiter in midfield, or down the channels looking for the strikers to run onto. The recent inclusions of loanee Scott Wharton and Eoghan O’Connell has increased their overall accuracy at the cost of sacrificing some speed and efficacy on the ground in the case of the latter.
As with most modern interpretations of the five-man defence, the wing-backs are the pivotal components of the Shakers’ XI. Wharton is beginning to foster a good rapport with Callum McFadzean on the left in particular, and O’Connell’s ability to pick out teammates at a distance can mean that Nicky Adams spends a touch more time concentrating on being on the front foot. It must be said that both of them are ostensibly wingers shoehorned into roles that ordinarily balance defensive and attacking duties, but such is the onus on taking the game to the opposition, more of it is given over to providing the width in the final third.
Rossiter has made the nominally more conservative of the two central midfield slots his own, relegating club captain Neil Danns to cameo roles from the substitutes’ bench. He has been the closest approximation to what was the ‘missing link’ in the side, intercepting loose balls with abandon, intelligently recycling possession, and being completely unafraid to simply ‘get stuck in’, despite his lengthy injury record. In turn, it’s freed Jay O’Shea to a certain extent to bomb on from deep, which he was apt to do anyway, but now with that added reassurance. The consistent scoring output from him has been a huge factor in relieving the pressure from the strikers, and has provided much food for thought when the opposing side sets up against Bury; in previous seasons, the threat would’ve almost solely come from Danny Mayor.
Speaking of whom, he has been back to his dazzling best in a free role in the left half-space, drifting inside to give room for McFadzean to overlap on the outside, and dragging his marker(s) infield along with him. This can often result in the hovering O’Shea being free at the edge of the box. An inside forward by trade, he’s not usually found putting crosses into the area, but using his incredible close control to dribble inside and cut back for one of the other five players normally camped there.
There is a reliance on Adams to float the ball in from out wide, and he tops both the attempts and assists chart in the fourth tier, in spite of not normally having a teammate known for their aerial prowess to aim for. Being somewhat proficient with his left foot gives him more angles to utilise when trying to pick someone out, which compensates for being a touch slower at the age of 32 than in his heyday.
In a largely settled XI, the only (frequent) rotation has come up front. Nicky Maynard’s exploits since joining as a free agent in October don’t require much elaboration, but he has looked in recent weeks like the only striker who’s going to score, and has even won games using his head, which he often cites as the weakest aspect of his attributes. Caolan Lavery has been partnering him of late, and he does offer a little more presence in the area than some of the internal competition. Dom Telford and the versatile Byron Moore are their replacements; both offer direct running both on and off the ball, and Moore can hold it out wide to wait for others to join in the attack.
When things haven’t been going Bury’s way, an even greater emphasis on attack has been deployed. This has sometimes entailed shifting McFadzean inside as the left-sided centre back who joins in forays forward, playing Moore as a wing-back on either flank, and bringing on Gold Omotayo to offer an obvious focal point in the penalty area. Whilst only a bit-part player in 2018/2019, the Swiss target man has been important in being a decoy for Maynard to roam undetected – that unlikely combination has won games in injury time twice in the last 10 league fixtures, and it might just be something we see more.
Form over last 10 league matches
Just like The Imps, Bury have been unbeaten in the league at the time of writing for 13 games, which few fans would’ve predicted after the first half-a-dozen matches back in the fourth tier yielded three of the total seven defeats. The sequence was started by a stirring comeback from 3-1 down to triumph 4-3 over MK Dons in the first of a trio of extremely challenging fixtures against most of the heavyweights in the division. It was followed up by a smash-and-grab style win at the New Lawn over Forest Green Rovers, again from behind. They then bounced back three times in the pulsating televised game at home against leaders Lincoln.
A much poorer perfomance on a half-frozen Gigg Lane pitch when Crawley Town came to visit was reflected in the 1-1 scoreline, but they were soon back to winning ways at fellow Lancashire outfit Morecambe, although they made hard work of it, almost conspiring to throw away a three-goal advantage. The long trip down to Exeter City provided a fortuitous victory, with Nicky Maynard’s scuffed shot going well wide until the (un)timely intervention of a Grecian defender.
The derby with Oldham Athletic finally yielded a (convincing) win on home turf for The Shakers, who were full value for their three goals after falling behind early in the proceedings. They were made to work hard by north-west neighbours Macclesfield Town for the points, but their class told in the end.
The moving forward of their encounter with Cheltenham Town at the Jonny-Rocks Stadium offered them a rare opportunity to temporarily knock Lincoln off top spot on goal difference, but despite utterly dominating possession (70% as the away side), they had to settle for a draw. That could’ve been a big blow psychologically, and Stevenage certainly offered no favours, largely shutting them down in the absence of Mayor. It took until the fourth minute of second half injury time to score, which was a massive filip after Mansfield’s travails in Burslem…
Remaining fixtures in more detail
Lowe’s charges have a week to recuperate from their last-gasp victory in Hertfordshire, and welcome a Cambridge United side inching their way to survival under Colin Calderwood. Though they have rarely notched more than a goal in any game this season, one of those occasions was against Bury at home in November, coming back from two down and a man light to share the spoils. They do possess some electric pace on the counter in the form of one-time Shaker David Amoo and Jevani Brown, and although I think the hosts ought to have enough to overcome them, that aspect cannot be ignored.
Seven days later, they face a streaky Grimsby Town at Blundell Park. Custodian James McKeown has been one of the most outstanding goalkeepers in the league this season, and they haven’t conceded too many as of late. The tussle between Rossiter and the very talented Elliott Embleton could have a big say on which way the outcome swings. Again though, this is one of the ‘kinder’ fixtures left to play away from home.
The 30th of March pits ‘Loweball’ versus ‘Wellensball’. There can be little doubt that Richie Wellens has picked Swindon Town’s squad up from the floor since his appointment, and a late surge for the play-offs remains a possibility, despite their setback at the weekend against fellow hopefuls Carlisle United. This is the home game I’m least sure about Bury getting something from. It’s unlikely they’ll survive the next nine games without tasting defeat at least once, and that match seems the likeliest candidate.
Either way, April looks quite tough. A trip to Brunton Park will almost certainly find the Cumbrians in a similar position to Swindon, and a draw would represent a good outcome. Lowe’s men will need to keep Jamie Devitt quiet to maximise their chances of three points. A home clash with a decidedly erratic Colchester United takes place a week later; although they have the quality to go up against anyone this season, it’s only been witnessed in fits and bursts. Any side containing Ben Stevenson and Sammie Szmodics to name but two should be watched closely.
Good Friday sees Bury travel to Newport County, who have one of the most potent striking partnerships in the division. Padraig Amond has been rewarded for his displays with a call-up to the Republic of Ireland, and Jamille Matt leads the line brilliantly for another side with possible pretensions of a play-off place. I foresee the match playing out a lot like the reverse fixture did, with the Exiles ceding territory to remain compact and frustrate the opposition.
Three days later, Northampton Town make the journey north to BL9. I was impressed by how quickly Keith Curle had galvanised his players in the 0-0 at Sixfields, and slowly but surely, they have been on an upward trajectory in 2019. Difficult to beat, they have only lost one more game than MK Dons, and in Aaron Pierre in defence, they possess a dominating centre back who is attracting attention from representatives of clubs two tiers higher.
By the time of the penultimate match with Tranmere Rovers, both teams’ fates should be clearer. The Birkenhead outfit are the only side chasing (or in) a play-off place in rude form, and with Connor Jennings a reliable supplier for the league’s top scorer in the shape of James Norwood, it’s sure to be an exciting occasion. Of course, there’s also the possibility that history might repeat itself – Prenton Park was the scene of Bury’s last promotion from the fourth tier in 2014/2015…
The final match sees the return of Tom Pope and Port Vale to Gigg Lane. Not quite out of a relegation fight just yet, the fixture could still be pivotal for both teams at either end of the standings. Under John Askey, the Valiants are slowly improving their attacking output, and by the same token, Lowe will be keen to round off the season in style – if that can’t be achieved, a win by any means will do.
Analysis & Prediction
Lowe has done all he can to quash talk in public of promotion, understandably refusing to look more than a game ahead “to get to where we want to get to”, which is back in League One at the first time of asking. Few predicted that at the start of 2018/2019, and no matter what happens now, it has been one of the best campaigns in decades, playing better football than at any other point in my 25 years of watching. However, there are no prizes for simply doing that, and some of the recent wins on the road, the lack of which had hitherto been the weakest aspect of the season, have had all the typical ‘grinding out’ qualities, with forgettable performances in the last three… but seven points to show for it.
If they can maintain the recent form of two points per game, they’ll break their own record for most points accrued in a single season since three were awarded for wins. There is a special feeling at the club right now, but it will still be a dogfight to maintain their grip on an automatic promotion place, let alone second. Picking up at least two victories in April will be key – if it happens and promotion does indeed follow, then there is a strong case for Lowe being awarded Manager of the Season. You only have to look at the contrast between now and 10 months ago to understand why. 3rd
Milton Keynes Dons
Most common recent XI, shape, and strategy
Callum Brittain’s recovery from three months out has helped Paul Tisdale restore a true three-man attack. MK build from the back, with the vast majority of custodian Stuart Moore’s passes being short to his central defenders, and his general distribution is accurate enough to be a good fit for that style of play. His height allows him to confidently claim crosses and corners.
Joe Walsh and Russell Martin will fan out slightly to cover for the forward runs of captain Dean Lewington and Brittain. Walsh is not the tallest of centre backs, but still wins his fair share of battles in the air. Martin is the more experienced and slower of the duo, and his accuracy at picking out teammates makes pressing the back four less of a viable option. Lewington’s crosses remain an important outlet for MK, and are complemented by Brittain’s efforts, helping to keep the threats more than singular from the flanks.
Ousseynou Cissé is a rangy presence in defensive midfield, gobbling up high balls and intercepting with aplomb. He also possesses a powerful shot and is a big threat from set pieces, and in open play, his reassuring presence helps maximise the efficacy of Alex Gilbey’s tireless shuttling between the lines and work rate. He is apt to shoot from range if other, more penetrative options are limited. He can occasionally try to be a little too cute with his through balls, but is a generally very consistent playmaker. Conor McGrandles is much more at home next to him than at right wing-back, and rarely gives the ball away cheaply in the engine room. He links well with Cissé and Gilbey, and doesn’t over-commit himself in the attacking phase.
Kieran Agard has not always had the goals tally to compare to his xG, but not that’s something that can be thrown at him this term, having racked up just short of 20. There will be a lot of swapping of positions in the three-pronged attack, and he has a tendency to drift wide in any case. He can be prone to being caught offside, which is often a consequence of playing on the shoulder of the last defender, full in the knowledge that he’d often win a foot race with them.
Even so, Chuks Aneke is perhaps the biggest danger of all. He will have the upper hand in most air wars with defenders, but he is most skillful in shaking off detection in the area, like any truly predatory striker. He averages almost four shots per game, proving that he doesn’t shy away from having another go if previously unsuccessful. Nominally on the left, he’ll often come deep to receive the ball, and then dribble towards goal with it in a positive manner. Far from the speediest individual, he’s still very difficult to prise the ball from.
David Wheeler or Jake Hesketh will complete the trio, although the latter is normally found peeling off the spearhead of the Dons to find space in between the lines. Queens Park Rangers loanee Wheeler is both good in the air and quick on the ground, the former of which helps him take up dangerous positions when Lewington floats the ball across. He’s not the same as Rhys Healey was, but he does help them stay in the final third for longer, and reach that area more quickly.
Form over last 10 league matches
The epitome of a mixed bag. Usually woeful on the road this season, Crewe Alexandra came to Stadium:MK and then left with all three points, but worse was to come in January. Despite playing for 50 minutes with 10 men, Grimsby Town still somehow managed to keep the Buckinghamshire outfit’s attack out, Wes Thomas’ strike before the sending off inflicting another loss on MK.
Something resembling the ‘old’ MK of their dominance in the latter part of 2018 was seen at home to Oldham Athletic. In truth, the margin could’ve been much wider than 2-1; it seemed as though they’d turned a corner. It proved to be a false dawn. A 3-1 reverse at an improving Exeter City, shorn of Jayden Stockley, continued to raise question marks in winter about their defence, which had looked so solid until the Christmas period. They conspired to concede three once more in their next outing, and suffered the ignominy of a Panenka in their own ground to seal victory for Swindon Town, but they were value for at least a point.
The last five games have all been wins, with noticeable improvements from Tisdale’s charges from even the first half of the campaign. Aneke struck late to secure victory at Newport County to give them a deserved three points. McGrandles, by this time shifted back into his preferred central midfield role, was the spark for their next maximum haul, coming off best in a five-goal thriller at Brunton Park, and they had to withstand concerted pressure to maintain their lead when they regained it in an eight-minute burst during the second half.
The rearranged game with the Exiles because of the South Wales outfit’s FA Cup exploits meant the reverse fixture fell just 11 days later. Once more, they shut their opponents out, a rare Cissé strike setting them on their way to victory. Agard got his name back on the scoresheet at home to Crawley Town in a tight encounter, and then last Saturday, Tisdale’s men mounted a comeback away at Macclesfield Town to overtake Mansfield Town in the third automatic promotion slot, having fallen out of the top seven entirely during their prior miserable spell of form.
Remaining fixtures in more detail
The recent bad weather seems to have spared their match tonight at Morecambe, who will put up plenty of fight but should be overcome. That fixture is followed on Saturday when they play hosts to Stevenage, who will be reliant on holding their two banks of four in a low line to scrape a result.
A second game at home in a row against Yeovil Town could give them a real opportunity to put together an eight-game winning run, and the way Forest Green Rovers are performing currently, I wouldn’t put it past Tisdale’s men to make it nine. Of course, Lincoln City are a different proposition altogether, and by that time, a creditable draw should cement at least third, if not second.
Tranmere Rovers will also provide a thorough examination of MK, and are bang in form themselves. Again, a share of the spoils would keep them and Mansfield at bay. Notts County will be hoping their fate isn’t already sealed by Good Friday; if not, they must go all-out to preserve their status as the oldest club in the EFL, and could spring a surprise in the process.
Mansfield found out the hard way that Port Vale aren’t perhaps as there for the taking as they’d imagined, but will find the going tough in Buckinghamshire. The final two games are both very tough. Colchester United might need the points to secure their play-off berth, and can be devastating when on song. Mansfield at home could have many permutations…
Analysis & Prediction
My gut feeling says it will be MK, not Bury, who will run Lincoln the closest, and the gap between the trio could be fewer than three points in the final standings. Tisdale had his doubters during a terrible January, but wasn’t helped by the recall by Cardiff City of Rhys Healey, nor the early injury to George Williams at Gigg Lane, who hasn’t featured since. The loan signings of Hesketh and Wheeler have reinforced an already strong attack, and Brittain’s calming presence has helped to tighten the defence after his own spell on the sidelines.
Tisdale also has a wealth of past experience to call upon to get his side over the line. Having failed at the final hurdle with Exeter City, he now has the resources and the form to ensure that their grip on 3rd at the very least doesn’t loosen. Games against the Imps and Stags could determine the difference between promotion and the championship. 2nd
Most common recent XI, shape, and strategy
Tyler Walker’s suspension was one of the chief reasons behind boss David Flitcroft’s decision to go with a flat back four during those games. His return should see the 3-4-1-2 make its reappearance, with playmaker Jacob Mellis shuttling in between the lines. Much like Lincoln, three different goalkeepers have had significant gametime – #1 choice Bobby Olejnik is sidelined with damaged cruciate ligaments for the remainder of 2018/2019, so Nottingham Forest loanee (a frequent occurrence this season) Jordan Smith now patrols the area, who will be hoping for better protection from the experienced backline than he’s been afforded in recent outings.
Ever-present captain Krystian Pearce marshals the rest of the defence superbly, which he combines with an imposing physicality and strong aerial skills. Ryan Sweeney’s concussion at Vale Park might delay the reversion to a three temporarily, although Matt Preston, a doubt for Crawley Town, could be the right-sided of the trio if he’s passed fit. He’s another colossus at the back, more apt to clear his lines quickly than pick out a teammate with a precise pass, but most successful teams need a mixture of the two. On the left, Mal Benning could be called upon to give that balance, although he has operated mostly in a full-back/wing-back role. He has been integral to the transition from the first to second third of the pitch, but will find those opportunities limited if asked to fill in more centrally, and the opposition could target his relative lack of height.
Hayden White’s lengthy injury has meant that several different individuals have been tried to fill his boots. CJ Hamilton is a completely different player to the aggressive White, and his attributes are very much attack-focused. He could be placed on the opposite wing in the short-term, having had a breakout season full of goals and torturing opposing defences. Gethin Jones is a more natural fit for that berth, and will prioritise maintaining the structure of the XI over forays forward.
Willem Tomlinson signed as a free agent after his release from Blackburn Rovers in early February, and has featured in the past four fixtures as the anchor man of the XI. His presence ensures that there’s never oceans of space for the other team to attack on the counter, and he is asked when he does regain possession to recycle the ball to Neal Bishop or Mellis. Bishop has been immense all season long, and is one of the favourites to claim the club’s Player of the Year award. He operates as the focal point in midfield, charging down loose balls, blocking counters, and using his vision to keep the Stags on the front foot. His movement during set pieces is excellent, and he normally finds a pocket of space in those situations to shoot from.
Mellis’ talents have never been in doubt, but his application often has. An attacking midfielder by trade, he has been forced to adapt to a deeper role by Flitcroft in particular during his previous spell at Bury and now in Nottinghamshire. He loves an effort from range and to play in big occasions, rising to prominence with strikes against Lincoln and MK Dons this term.
Grant has mostly taken over set piece duties from Mellis, and after a strong start in blue and yellow, has begun to attract some criticism for not putting his foot in. Nevertheless, his ability will be required to break the deadlock as games get tighter. He has demonstrated how effective he can be with both feet, using his speed to get in behind to get shots off or to cut back to a teammate.
The options are numerous in attack when all of the players are available for selection. Ajose could just as easily be paired with Walker as Grant, and he enjoys playing on the shoulder of the last defender to finish from angles normally on the right-hand side of the area, and he also has the presence of mind to drift to the far post to latch onto crosses and loose balls, dragging his marker with him if the latter notices at all.
As the lynchpin of the team, Walker is a pacey dribbler and lethal in the penalty area with both his left and right foot. He is brave when challenging for the ball aerially in the six yard box, and involves himself in several stages of the attack, dropping off the frontline to receive and pass the ball quickly, ably supported by good numbers to hem in the opposition.
Form over last 10 league matches
Exchanging positions with Bury over the period, Mansfield kicked off with a routine, if late, victory over Crawley Town, Tyler Walker once again being the difference maker at a vital juncture. They then impressively came back from a two-goal deficit to claim the win away to Colchester United, three second half strikes from their bevy of attacking talent capping off a battling performance in which a draw might have been the fairer result.
No such question marks lingered over their thrashing of Tranmere Rovers. Ollie Banks’ dismissal at 1-0 down severely curtailed the Birkenhead side’s threat, and the Stags added two more to their tally. A good point was then gained at The New Lawn, although I’m sure Flitcroft would have been a little disappointed that Forest Green Rovers restored parity, given that his charges had been leading for so long.
Macclesfield Town were swatted aside back at Field Mill, Walker making certain of the win just before injury time. The away defeat against Newport County marked the first in an ongoing losing sequence on the road. Wayward shooting was as much the cause of their downfall as the hosts’ ability to shut them out, only getting a single effort on target.
Beleaguered Notts County were transformed in their derby match, barely giving their rivals a kick at Meadow Lane – Craig Mackail-Smith bagged the priceless winner for the Magpies, ensuring bragging rights and a fighting chance of survival.
However, Mansfield regained a sense of normality in their own backyard, Walker notching the winner before being sent off in one of the most ridiculous momentary lapses of reason I’ve ever seen. His suspension didn’t seem to affect the rest of the team when they bested Cheltenham Town, scoring four in the process. The versatile CJ Hamilton got a brace to set them on their way. The Robins did hit back twice before the hosts returned the favour to hold onto third place.
Port Vale should have been the game to resurrect their worrying run away, but Nicky Ajose’s penalty was saved with the match 0-0. The Valiants then found a hero in talisman Tom Pope’s absence in the shape of Ricky Miller’s unlikely double. Ajose did make amends for his earlier miss to provide a pathway back into the game, but the Burslem outfit held firm and looked dangerous on the counter. That costly defeat has seen them fall to fourth, with Flitcroft now questioning the desire of several of his players in away trips at the worst possible time.
Remaining fixtures in more detail
As their rivals have found out, banking on a win at Crawley Town is a foolish mentality to have. Walker will be back from his needless suspension, and that should mean a reversion to a back three with several new fades in the XI. Should they salvage one or all three points from West Sussex, they could then have a squeak of a chance of the title if they can get the better of leaders Lincoln City, but that’s a tall order even during a purple patch of form.
They ought to have a better time of it at home to Crewe Alexandra. The Railwaymen will almost certainly have to be content with a comfortable mid-table position, and the Stags should dominate the midfield. The journeys far from home comforts don’t get much kinder; Exeter City still harbour play-off dreams of their own, and a draw would represent a decent outcome.
Cambridge United might be safe from the relegation zone by this point, and I expect Flitcroft to take full advantage of that. An improving Northampton Town are another tricky proposition, and it will likely take a performance with plenty of cutting edge to wrestle three points from Sixfields.
Morecambe at home on Good Friday is a match that screams ‘banana skin’, particularly if The Shrimps are still looking over their shoulders at the bottom two. Jim Bentley always sets his side up to scrap for every ball to compensate for the shortfall in quality he has at his disposal. The Boundary Park pitch doesn’t do sides that like to play on the deck any favours, but the fixture with Oldham Athletic looks like their best bet of all to win. Stevenage have seen their season peter out disappointingly over recent weeks, and the Stags shouldn’t have too many causes for concern in that one.
All roads lead to Milton Keynes to take on the Dons. I’ve discussed the possible scenarios in my analysis of the Buckinghamshire outfit’s remaining matches, so there’s no need to duplicate that, other than to put forward the notion that ifFlitcroft needs a win to secure promotion, it’s about the worst possible fixture to try to attain it.
Analysis & Prediction
An expensively assembled squad looked odds-on to consign the disappointing collapse of 2017/2018 to history, losing just once in the first half of the current campaign. Yes, plenty of those were draws, but they were a good platform to build upon for the latter stages. Flitcroft has gained a reputation as a streaky manager, and that tag is not wholly undeserved. The damaging loss of someone like White would hinder any side in the division, but he has yet to find a satisfactory solution, which underlines just how important the wing-back role is in most systems today. Openly questioning some players’ desire and resolve, whether it has merit, is a risky move with 10 games remaining, having just given up the final automatic place.
Talent-wise, all four teams are fairly even, and the main separators are the men in the dugout. Walker is someone who can win games on his own, and the spine looks strong. However, there are more tricky games on the road to come, and they might have to settle for a play-off spot, even if they can convert some of those losses to draws. 5th
Can anyone else gatecrash the automatic promotion places?
Current standings below the top four
Though just four points separate 5th to 9th, I feel that a plausible case can only currently be made for Tranmere Rovers. Their past six games have yielded 16 points, and they’ve only conceded a single goal. Other than them, only Colchester United are in any kind of form, and they veer from spectacular to shambolic with little rhyme or reason. I think Bury are beyond reach of the Birkenhead outfit, but they are the best placed side to take advantage of any further slips from Mansfield or another MK Dons poor patch. They still have to play all of the top three, so they could have a huge hand in the title race, as well as their own pretensions. They’ve ‘chosen’ the best time to spring to life, and though their fixture list is tough on paper, many of the games are against fellow play-off hopefuls listing woefully. Should they ‘fail’ to break in, they are strongly placed to carry forward their late surge into the play-off games themselves. I can see them finishing an oustanding 4th.
EFL Trophy, and competing against third tier sides
Let’s begin with a negative – losing last night at home to Portsmouth 3-0 in the semi-final, with a place at Wembley the prize on offer. I made a brief radio appearance (10 minutes or so into the clip), full in the knowledge from reading local news sources that Pompey boss Kenny Jackett would break with the pattern he’d established in previous rounds of the competition, and name what was essentially the visitors’ strongest available lineup, and was even able to leave the likes of Jamal Lowe on the subs’ bench for the first half.
There were some parallels to the FA Cup tie against Luton Town to how the game eventually panned out – the hosts were on top for large expanses of time, didn’t get the crucial opener (not for lack of trying), and a shrewd tactical tweak changed the course of proceedings. Yes, one or two decisions were a little contentious, but Bury didn’t really have an answer to the Hampshire outfit’s higher press, and there’s no shame in that. The scoreline was on the flattering side, but I think Ryan Lowe and his players will have learned a lot from their experiences pitting their wits across two different cups against six League One sides, winning and losing half of them, and more impressively, scoring 13 in the process.
You can also see as a fan particular areas where the current squad could be improved if they gain promotion back at the first time of asking. There’s little reason to suggest at this moment in time that the manager will make big changes in the summer tactically or personnel-wise, and I’m certain that between him and Director of Sport Lee Dykes, they’ll have identified well in advance of the window re-opening a cluster of targets to bring through the doors to augment an already talented group, as well as offering some of the most promising U18s deals (which I’ll get on to later in this post). As soon as the first team’s division is confirmed for 2019/2020, I’ll put together my own ‘wishlist’ of realistic signings, and how they could specifically improve a system that’s unlikely to drastically alter.
The immediate efficacy of Jordan Rossiter
Understandably, there were question marks over his loan capture from giants Glasgow Rangers, owing totally to injury concerns, rather than his undoubted ability. He didn’t start against Crawley Town on a half-frozen pitch, but did make his bow at the opening of the second period, and has barely put a foot wrong since. Captain Neil Danns has had to be largely content watching on from the sidelines during February, and it’s not hard to see why in the two videos below:
In a regular XI where previously seven of the 10 outfielders were unquestionably attack-minded, the addition of Rossiter into the mix probably takes that figure down to a much more conservative six-and-a-half. One of the most basic tenets of being an effective professional footballer is to always seek the ball, even in tight situations. As the clips more than ably demonstrate, he does just that, which can be a decisive factor in breaking the opposition’s high press onto the defensive trio.
He covers the gaps in deep areas, recycles the ball to teammates, plays smart passes that can look deceptively simple, very rarely wastes possession, intercepts with gusto, and despite his injury record, he relishes putting in the tackles. I did have some concerns that the introduction of a player in that role might have slowed down the high-octane style Lowe has employed, but I don’t think that’s been the case at all.
A running total of five games is a small sample size, but his completed passes average stands at 84%, and was as high as 90% at the weekend, attempting 70 in total just by himself. At St. James Park, he seemed omnipresent, breaking up promising Grecian attack after attack on no fewer than 15 occasions, as is abundantly clear above.
Additionally, he’s been named man of the match for the past three games in a row. Not only is that remarkable because of being new to the club and his position, it also makes him stand out even more during a season where the Shakers have been praised far and wide for their attacking endeavour, which has at times not left sufficient room for column inches or credit for the likes of Adam Thompson, Will Aimson, or anyone else tasked primarily with defensive duties. I have seen some criticism of the back three as a whole, some of which is valid, but some of it goes over the top, and pointing to the goals conceded column doesn’t tell the whole story.
After the long-awaited derby day triumph against Paul Scholes’ Oldham Athletic™, he received glowing praise from his temporary boss, with Lowe describing the deal to bring him south of border for six months as:
"The best bit of business I've ever done, or ever likely to!"
A cynic might suggest he’s only had three transfer windows in temporary and subsequently permanent charge to make such a claim, but if you’ve seen (m)any of his interviews, you’d understand he’s usually very reluctant to heap too much adulation onto one player, let alone come out with a statement like that. The addition of ‘ever likely to’ at what is still the very early stages of his managerial career is actually the most telling part of that sentence, and underlines the great value he can bring during his short spell.
He has endeared himself to supporters in such a ridiculously short space of time – the winning combination of maximum effort plus real ability will never not do that, but it’s certainly made me, and plenty of others, believe that he will be the key player from now until the end of 2018/2019.
The versatility of Byron Moore & Callum McFadzean
Has anyone in the current squad played in as many different areas as Byron Moore over the past seven months? I solely regarded him as an out-and-out winger in a four or five-man midfield upon his arrival, but it soon became apparent that Lowe had other plans for the 30 year-old, especially as the usual shape of the side doesn’t even accommodate that position. A cursory glance on Wyscout illustrates he’s played in every outfield role for a decent chunk of time, with the sole exception of centre back!
Up until the Portsmouth match, he had looked quite adept in the left wing-back area, but I’m unsure the combinations down the left with Danny Mayor and Callum McFadzean weren’t a little too cavalier, and at certain intervals, the first two would try to operate in a very small space in that channel. Expecting absolute consistency from any individual in the fourth tier, especially one that has had so many jobs to do, is unrealistic. His wide skillset has meant, however, that his manager has been able to call on a core squad of 20 in the second phase of the season, assisted by an unusually empty treatment room, and very few disciplinary issues of any kind on the field.
Whilst not quite on the same Swiss Army knife level as his teammate, McFadzean, by his admission better going forward than the other way, has been deployed as the left-sided centre back on numerous occasions, usually in an effort to push everyone else even further up the pitch when chasing a game. It seemed to have the right effect last night for most of the first half. However, it did then get exploited by a resurgent Pompey with Jamal Lowe’s introduction, with all three of their goals coming from that area. With Scott Wharton cup-tied and possibly still out with a knock, he was probably preferred to Chris Stokes due to his greater pace, possibly at the cost of a little more experience and solidity.
Nevertheless, both Moore and McFadzean were largely unheralded when they signed in the close season, and yet have turned out to be invaluable to the team, improving as the campaign has unfolded.
Nicky Maynard, the poacher
Unlucky not to add to his tally of 17 goals in all competitions last night, he came up against an inspired Craig MacGillvray between the Portsmouth sticks with an arcing effort that seemed destined to nestle into the bottom far corner. His otherwise fruitful month was characterised by four efforts that could only be labelled as a ‘poacher’s’ – just about getting enough on the ball to poke home against Crawley Town; an inadvertent one-two with Exeter City’s Dean Moxey for a truly scruffy strike; bundling the ball over the line for his first against the Latics, and then capitalising on some woeful defending for his second within the six-yard area.
Even if that was the case, it would still speak volumes about his positioning to peel off his marker, and setting his body correctly in anticipation of a pass or inadvertent opportunity. Ugly goals they might have been of late, but the aesthetics matter not, and he’s certainly demonstrated he’s capable of the spectacular, too.
Another unbeaten month in the league & 12 games left…
Once more, Ben Mayhew’s xG timelines demonstrate the different ways Bury have remained unbeaten in the four league games contested during February:
The table is starting to take shape with just a quarter of the campaign left. Long-time leaders Lincoln City drew 1-1 last night with Exeter City, in a result that probably suits Bury more than a decisive outcome either way. I’m not going to go into much depth here about how I think things will pan out for all the runners and riders – I’ll save that for a separate post a little into March.
The Lancashire outfit will need to bounce back from their disappointment quickly, with three matches in the space of a week, beginning this Saturday with the visit of Macclesfield Town to BL9. Under Sol Campbell, they have risen a place but are still in the relegation zone, taking 20 points from a possible 45 during his tenure. Winless in five, they have nevertheless been very competitive in every game, and have only suffered defeat by a margin of more than once in that period – away at Mansfield Town, which is no disgrace.
That fixture is swiftly followed by a journey down to the Jonny-Rocks Stadium to face Cheltenham Town. On a four-match winning run in Gloucestershire, they have taken vital, maximum points from the teams around them as a consequence. Although they were soundly beaten 4-1 in the reverse fixture, the scoreline was harsh on Mike Duff’s men, who looked especially dangerous down both flanks when floating crosses in to Luke Varney. It’s at this juncture where teams in or around the bottom six often start picking up ‘unexpected’ scalps, and nothing can be taken for granted.
On the 9th of March, the outspoken Dino Maamria will welcome the Shakers to his corner of Hertfordshire. Stevenage are nothing if not wildly inconsistent, and it’s still not out of the question for them to put some form together to trouble the top seven. The obvious qualities Queens Park Rangers loanee Ilias Chair possesses will need to be somehow kept in check; Lincoln didn’t manage to do that, and were very nearly three points worse off for that one failure in a recent clash.
Cambridge United are badly struggling for goals once more, having only notched on a single occasion in their last five outings at the time of writing. A more than respectable January (drubbing by Milton Keynes Dons aside) gave way to a decidedly barren February, and they were extremely fortunate to best Port Vale for their solitary win. That said, Colin Calderwood should look to how his predecessor Joe Dunne disrupted Bury back in November by employing a high press and a mid-block in defence, and emulate that as best as he can to obtain something from the match.
Michael Jolley’s Grimsby Town are on an upward curve since the beginning of December, and like Stevenage, are an outside bet to gatecrash the play-off positions. Admittedly, their January results were poor on the face of it, but most sides would count even one win in four against the top teams as commendable, which came over MK at Blundell Park, despite being a man lighter for more than half the game. Unbeaten in February, they will be a much tougher prospect than they appeared to be back in the nascent part of the season.
Similarly, Swindon Town are experiencing a renaissance of sorts under Richie Wellens, who’s making more out of the technical players at his disposal. If anyone currently lower than ninth is going to be in the reckoning come May, they would be my pick. For the most part, their run-in games are against fellow mid-table sides who will potentially have little to play for by then. Triumphs over MK and Forest Green Rovers in the past month demonstrate that they have the capability in one-off games to compete with the ‘elite’ of the fourth tier, and are the most technically comparable side to Bury in terms of style and mentality. It should be an intriguing game to round off March, and the complexion will be much clearer by the end of it.
FA Youth Cup
There is at least one Bury side still in a cup competition (actually two, but I’ll get to that in the section below!). Ryan Kidd’s youngsters have a mouth-watering clash at Gigg Lane, hosting Liverpool U18s in the quarter-final stage. Should they manage to find a way through one of the best academies in the world, they’ll be on home soil once more to Watford or Leicester City in a single leg, which is the first change in format for 40 years. The two ties have already been played in the ‘other’ half of the draw, and Bury now stand alone as the only Category 3 and lower tier representatives in the competition.
The magnitude of next Wednesday evening’s occasion shouldn’t be underestimated, and I’ll be talking to two people who have kept close tabs on the Reds’ fortunes under new boss Barry Lewtas this season for this blog.
Few will be expecting a shock home win, of course, and as someone who takes a very keen interest in youth football, it’s always tempting to overstate some of the current crop’s potential, even though I try to remain as objective as possible. That said, they are at the late stage for good reason; Callum Hulme and Joe Adams have been offered (and accepted) pro contracts, and I suspect at least four of the other second year scholars will receive similar terms, if that hasn’t taken place already away from the public eye.
Below them, there is now a reliable stream of quality coming through, which is testament to the work Kidd, Mark Litherland, Graham Hastings, and others have put in over the last half-decade. Put another way, there’s good reason Femi Seriki was mentioned unpromptedby Lowe before last night’s match, where he suggested that the versatile 15 year-old right-sided forward could be in line for his senior debut before the season is over. There was also a reason why he was on the bench earlier on in the course of the EFL Trophy…
It’s difficult to avoid language that makes the boys sound like commodities to be pinched off the club for a pittance, but such is the pervasiveness of EPPP, it’s an onerous task to do so, and even harder to keep them from the watchful gazes of scouts at teams with larger resources. That’s why it’s important to cherish the current group aiming for glory next week. I expect them to line up in a positive 4-3-3 to try to go beyond the midfield diamond that’s a staple of the Reds’ lineups in 2018/2019. They can’t afford to be boxed in to their own third of the pitch, but should hopefully have a sizeable backing in the stands to aid their cause.
Two women’s sides challenging for trophies
Lying in second place but with only a single promotion spot on offer, Scott Johnson’s senior women’s side face table-toppers Blackpool away this Sunday, having beaten the Seasiders 10 days ago at Carrington. Even a draw would still be advantageous, as they are currently seven points behind with three games in hand. Victories in the other seven fixtures would ensure promotion to the fifth tier of the female pyramid, and whilst that is a tall order, the four other confirmed matches for March are against opposition they’ve already either beaten comfortably, or who are struggling at the other end of NW Division One North. The three leading scorers in the white and royal blue are having their own tussle for supremacy – captain and taliswoman (if it isn’t a word already, I’ve coined it now!) Lucy Golding leads the way with 14 to her name despite playing a deeper role, but Jordon Bailey (13) and Caitlin Clancy (11) are both hot on her heels, having notched match-winning braces in the last two matches.
The reserve side lead the way in their smaller pool, and thanks to some walkovers and clubs withdrawing, they only have one league match left to contest. A win over Stanwix Juniors would ensure them of at least second, but much like the senior outfit, they need top spot for promotion. Colin Platt’s charges would still be reliant on Sunday’s opponents slipping up elsewhere, as their goal difference is vastly inferior to the Carlisle natives. Later on in the month, they have the Lancashire County Plate cup final against higher tier opposition in the form of Nelson on neutral ground in Leyland. If you’re in the area on the morning of the 17th of March, they’d certainly appreciate you coming down to watch them lift some silverware!
2018/2019 stats (for Glasgow Rangers in all competitions): 181 minutes, 2 starts, 3 sub appearances; 0 goals, 0 assists.
By now, you’ll have seen the superbly put together video of the ‘worst kept secret’ of the winter transfer deadline day. Just like Ryan Lowe said during his interview yesterday, I would never have expected the likes of Jordan Rossiter at the club, although it becomes a little easier to understand why when you look at his career trajectory in the past five years, with two hugely contributory factors weighing him down in my view.
⚪️🔵📝 SIGNING: Here it is, the worst kept secret of #DeadlineDay!
Firstly, and most obviously, it’s his injury record. Assuming his page on Transfermarkt is reasonably accurate, to have so many lengthy spells on the sidelines at such a young age can only have had a massive impact on him, but it also says a lot about his character and mental toughness to have fought his way back to fitness so many times. Unfortunately, having so many knockbacks will inevitably start to attract ire, derision, and this can then take the form of ‘banter’ about him spending more time in Fairfield General Hospital than he will on the Gigg Lane turf. You just have to accept that some people will resort to that, given how much focus professional footballers are under, particularly ones with Rossiter’s profile.
A local Liverpool lad, he entered the academy at just six, and rose through each age bracket with glowing references, and made his debut at 15 in the now-defunct NextGen Series, a continental cup competition designed principally for U19 players… which brings me to the second issue. A strong showing as a substitute in that game against Inter Milan was sufficient for Reds legend Robbie Fowler to draw comparisons between him and Steven Gerrard:
A young lad just about to come on for a few mins for Liverpool in nextgen… Jordan rossiter, big shout but potentially a young stevie g..
I’m sure it was meant as only the highest praise, but that is an extremely heavy mantle to have to take on whilst still an adolescent. Of course, it’s far from a unique situation to him, but I’ve always found it a lazy, often damaging way of describing a player, which both sets fans up to have unrealistic expectations, and the label can become internalised by the individual him/herself, making it that much more difficult to enjoy their football and progress.
One thing that’s rarely been questioned is Rossiter’s actual ability, as that tweet attests to. In compiling this Scouting Report, there is a bevy of evidence to support the claims that have always been made about him, but it is unavoidably scattered over a large expanse of time.
Capped up to England U20s level, he’s been used exclusively at club and international levels as either a defensive or central midfielder. His strong left foot, which he’s nearly as adept with as his right, has meant often being chosen to be the left of a midfield duo or trio in order to utilise this facet of his game more extensively. His career passing accuracy to date is just a shade lower than 90%, with around a third of his total being played forward, and his impressive array and range has helped to unlock defences from deep areas on the pitch, in not too dissimilar a way to former Celtic prospect Eoghan O’Connell’s recent exploits for the Shakers.
Whilst not the quickest, which has doubtlessly been exacerbated by persistent calf and hamstring problems, he does cover a lot of ground in every phase, which will be a crucial aspect under Ryan Lowe’s system without the ball. Equally as handy is his ability to really get stuck in, and he’s just as apt to recover possession in the opposition half as he is his own. This could be of great help in reducing the number of instances Bury get countered upon, especially when coupled with how well he retains the ball.
In my review of January, I identified that as perhaps the weakest part of the current tactics. Rossiter is not a silver bullet for all that’s given up in defence for the sake of attack, but he does offer a skillset that’s hard to replicate, and is testament to the coaching he received at Melwood and more recently at the Rangers Training Centre; strong in the tackle, decent in the air, a natural with both feet, quite positive when passing, likes a shot from range, and most importantly in a sense, he loves to drive forwards, which will be key to how well he meshes into the XI when called upon. With Neil Danns on international duty with Guyana in March to try to earn qualification to the Gold Cup, there is a place up for grabs in his absence, if indeed he hasn’t already established himself by then.
It remains to be seen whether he’ll start tomorrow as Crawley Town make the journey north from West Sussex, but I think he’ll definitely feature at some point. There’s little chance that he’s been brought here at the expense of possible alternatives in the SPFL and the third tier of England to sit on the bench, and much of the credit must go to Lowe’s friendship with Gerrard to help persuade him and the rest of the Glasgow Rangers setup to send a second player from Ibrox to BL9 this campaign. Jamie Barjonas didn’t feature as much as he or his parent club would have liked, but in truth, Rossiter is a different prospect from the outset from his teammate, and that’s not meant to in any way diminish Barjonas, who will now spend the remainder of the campaign at Raith Rovers in a similar pursuit of regular minutes.
To give you an illustration of just how at odds 2018/2019 is the years immediately preceding it, Sporting Director Lee Dykes, together with Lowe, has ensured that the squad has been reduced in size, two of the leading lights in the U18s have signed pro terms, andnone of the ‘core’ senior contingent have been sold at an important juncture. Only Scott Wharton and Rossiter have arrived at Carrington, and they both eptiomise quality over quantity in positions that needed strengthening to maintain the tilt for automatic promotion. It’s equally plausible that the latter is ‘above’ the Shakers’ relatively low standing, as I’ve seen suggested both within and without the club, but as good as he is and could prove to be, I don’t feel as though the collective success is all hinging on him being a success in his time there. He has retained a positive outlook in the face of adversity on several occasions, and that will help him no end in fitting into the squad, no matter how much he does or doesn’t end up playing.
After the conclusion of Tuesday night’s matches, things couldn’t be tighter in the standings immediately below pacesetters Lincoln City. The 1-1 draw between Forest Green Rovers and Mansfield Town has ensured the former didn’t take full advantage of their game in hand on Bury by drawing level on points with their rivals, and in the latter’s case, it kept them within striking distance.
Milton Keynes Dons halted a truly insipid 2019 thus far by turning in an ugly 2-1 win over Oldham Athletic. Paul Tisdale won’t care a jot that the performance in the last 30 minutes left a lot to be desired, and they still have a game in hand on the four teams above them (away to Newport County in February).
Carlisle United continue to confound critics, and are the division’s form team over the last six, gaining 15 points from a possible 18. Recently installed manager Steven Pressley has been able to keep the momentum the Cumbrians had enjoyed under John Sheridan, and has added to their creative options in the past couple of days, bringing a little more depth to the squad.
In other words, it’s going to be a fiercely competitive conclusion to the campaign. When there are 10 matches remaining, I’ll revisit the standings, assess the top seven’s strengths and weaknesses, and try to predict the unpredictable…
Goals, goals, goals!
Just like two months ago, the Shakers have once more racked up the goals, adding another 22 to their tally for the season. Now standing at 80, they are behind only Manchester City with their total across the top 92 clubs in English football. Manager Ryan Lowe promised entertaining, attacking football under his stewardship, and whilst it arguably (and completely understandably) took a little while for things to come to fruition, his side have consistently delivered on that front beyond all reasonable expectations, and have now acquired the label of being ‘League Two’s Entertainers’, a phrase that evokes memories of Kevin Keegan’s Newcastle United from the mid-90s. Ultimately, his sides fell just short of wrestling the Premier League title away from Manchester United, and have come to be associated more as glorious failures. Fans and staff at Bury alike must be hoping that in a sense, the current crop can go one better and achieve promotion.
One of the most pleasing aspects of the glut has been that no single player has been relied upon for either creating the opportunities or finishing them off. The likes of Nicky Maynard, Jay O’Shea, and Dom Telford are now all on a dozen or more for the campaign, and could be set to be joined on double figures by Danny Mayor (9) and Byron Moore (8) before too long. I can’t recall any previous season where so many individuals have had such numbers in the white and royal blue. The wing-backs have been crucial in working the space to put crosses into the area, but again, the methods have been similarly numerous; 10 have come from outside the box in the league, and 14 have been scored with the left foot, which is a particularly interesting statistic, given that only two of the regular starting outfielders complete most of their actions using that one.
Another aspect to consider is the general difficulty of the opponents faced during January; the EFL Trophy matches pitted third tier outfits against the Shakers, and a three-match sequence in the league could barely have looked more challenging – MK Dons (home), Forest Green (away), and leaders Lincoln (home). Taking all of that into account, to rack up nine goals in the two cup games, and the same return against three of the best four teams in League Two is nothing short of remarkable. It should also be noted that in the cases of MK Dons and the Imps, no other side has put that many goals in a single game against them in the league – four and three respectively, ably demonstrating Bury’s ability to compete against the cream of the crop, and do serious damage to their hitherto tight defences in the process.
Once more, Ben Mayhew’s xG timelines demonstrate the different ways Bury have remained unbeaten in January:
‘Not the best without the ball’ – can it be fixed?
All that said, it would be remiss to overlook the fact that 13 goals were also conceded in the seven fixtures. Certainly, the quality of the opponents are a mitigating factor, but it’s hard to assuage the strong perception that a decent number of them were on the softer side. Lincoln boss Danny Cowley rightly stated that without the ball, there’s plenty of scope to hurt Bury, and it’s not hard to see why.
In a typical attack that originates from playing out from the back, the ball is then normally given short to one of the wing-backs or Neil Danns as the nominally more defensive-minded of the central midfield pairing.
Obviously, in a strategy geared for attack, it has many inherent advantages, especially if by always having a reliable out-ball, you can escape the high press many of their recent opponents have sought to deploy. Movement off the ball is still the most important aspect of the tactic (and probably in the sport as a whole), and when you have the likes of Mayor and O’Shea in midfield areas, the unexpected can often occur that aids greatly in penetrating even a deep backline.
One of the most joyous things for me about football is that there’s no such thing as a perfect tactic or strategy; as a result, new innovations come into being, become more widespread, and are in turn superseded by something else altogether. It doesn’t take the most analytical of scouts to understand that there are two key weaknesses in Lowe’s current implementation: firstly, they can be countered upon fairly easily. The lack of numbers in defence and the preference for silk over steel in central midfield both mean that the ball can be distributed at pace from both open play and dead ball situations consistently almost as soon as it’s won back by the opposition.
Bury often look panicky at these times, not principally in my opinion because any one player is not up to the task, but because the onus is firmly on selecting attack-minded individuals, who then have a lot of ground to cover to get back to their own goal to recover possession. Additionally, the most selected XI give up at least two inches in height to the vast majority of other teams in the league, which doesn’t just manifest itself from set plays, but also from long, raking balls hit down the channels, where they are often found wanting in winning either the first or second challenge.
I don’t see an easy fix in the short-term. In the close season, and regardless of which division they find themselves in for the 2019/2020 campaign, I’d like to see a tweaking of it. There’s every chance that change might come in the form of Mayor’s departure, which, if it did happen, might mean sacrificing the free role he had ahead of Danns and O’Shea, and shifting it back behind them to act as a counterbalance to possible strategies thought up by other managers, and a calming influence to what has actually been a good backline this season.
Chris Stokes, and the loan signing of Scott Wharton
It has been the former Coventry City’s ‘turn’ to receive criticism from some quarters in recent weeks. On the one hand, it’s inescapable that he had a big part in all three of Tisdale’s charges’ strikes on my annual visit, including an own goal. However, he then followed up that woeful outing with a man-of-the-match display at The New Lawn, repaying the faith Lowe has in him and the rest of the regular starters; the boss has already demonstrated through both rhetoric and action that he won’t discard someone on the basis of one or two below-par performances in quick succession.
Unfortunately, he was again second-best in last week’s outings, and was substituted in both instances. The loan capture of Scott Wharton, who had donned the red, black, and white of promotion rivals Lincoln for the equivalent of a full year, puts added pressure on his position. The Blackburn Rovers centre back is more of a specialist left-sided centre back than Stokes is, which isn’t a huge surprise, given that the latter only played 680 minutes in that role in the three seasons prior to joining Bury.
Although an inch shorter than his new and more experienced teammate, Wharton is much more dominant in the air, and at the very least Stokes’ equivalent with the ball at his feet. The percentages for successful passes aren’t as kind during his previous loan spell away from Ewood Park, but that can at least be partly explained by a vastly different style the Cowley brothers have devised, which has brought them no small degree of success.
It’s been said on several occasions that Tony Mowbray and his backroom staff were unhappy at the number of minutes Wharton was afforded at Sincil Bank in the first half of 2018/2019. How much that’s likely to change is up for debate right now. At the very worst, he’ll be a more than capable option for Lowe to bring on during matches. At best, he’ll usurp Stokes in the final stretch of games, but I have the feeling both of them will be required to do their part before the season is over. Stokes has had to adapt to two different roles that are largely unfamiliar to him during this term, both of which have at times served to accentuate his weaknesses rather than his strengths. It’s important for supporters to keep that in mind when assessing him, or any other player instructed to perform a certain role/position. The ceaseless attacking nature will only further magnify mistakes the few defensive-minded individuals make, and they’re put into one-on-one situations far more frequently than most of their equivalents in other sides can expect to be.
One of the standout performers away from the headliners higher up the pitch has been the ball-playing Irish centre back, who has been utilised exclusively as a defensive midfielder in January’s games, particularly when Bury have been chasing a result. Although he lacks the speed and mobility of even the 36 year-old Danns, his penchant for pinging 40 to 50 forward passes to their intended target has helped no end in regaining control in this kind of scenario.
Against Accrington, he ran the show; as a sub in the extraordinary fightback against MK Dons, he didn’t misplace a single pass, and laid on an assist for Telford to halve the arrears. Consistent displays in the other games saw him chosen ahead of the captain for the Lincoln clash, and was arguably one of the better performers in that match, and also saw a curling effort disallowed for no immediately discernible reason.
As ever, it’s ensuring that the immense promise he has (he’s still only 23) is harnessed properly, and his displays of late have left me wondering what his best position in future is. He probably doesn’t have the requisite raw pace to play in a two-man central defence, especially if that rearguard isn’t well-protected. In a three-man setup, this is best hidden by being the central component, where his aerial prowess is also most needed… but it would also mean shifting Adam Thompson into a wider space, which would both be unfair and unwise. With Wharton signing, it all but confirms my suspicion that he’ll mostly be played ahead of the defensive line, at least for the remainder of the current season.
Comeback wins (and draw!)
Equally as important as the remaining unbeaten in January has been finding another way to win. Coming from behind to triumph is often said to exemplify a certain togetherness in the group (and in the stands). Statistically, it tends to be rare for obvious reasons. Much rarer still is the ability to do it for three matches in a row against quality opposition. A Shakers outfit missing a few of their more high profile names in the first half at Accrington Stanley roared back from 2-0 down to win by two clear goals in the second period to progress in the EFL Trophy.
Even more inexplicably, they were 3-1 down at home to MK Dons with 18 minutes left of normal time, yet still somehow conspired to overturn that deficit in one of the most stirring, exciting games seen in BL9 for decades. Just as brilliantly in some ways, they then travelled to Nailsworth for the very first time, and although they were distinctly second best in spells of the game to an excellent footballing side in Forest Green, but just had that clinical edge that can make all the difference in tightly contested affairs.
One way of framing the six-goal thriller on Sky Sports last Saturday would be to say that at no point during the encounter were Lincoln behind, and that augurs well for the Imps. I can certainly go along with that train of thought, and to score three at Gigg Lane, even with the leakiest defence in the top seven, is unlikely to be repeated this season, with only the two pre-season favourites having achieved that at the time of writing. Avoiding defeat in that game was crucial for both sides, and has only solidified in my mind my belief that the visitors will taste title glory in May, but also that Bury are now in a position to give anyone in the division more than a bloody nose. Even the away form, which had previously been like a weight chained to their automatic promotion hopes, has picked up of late.
The bond between the squad and the supporters hasn’t been as strong as it is now for quite some time, and probably not since the last successful bid to escape the fourth tier. Yes, performances and stirring wins from losing positions help, but simply seeing that they all care is usually enough to maintain that connection. Lowe will be keen to find a formula that keeps the need for comebacks to a minimum, but the work that has gone on behind the scenes to turn things around to this point is nothing short of astonishing.
One game from Wembley
As well as going better in the league than most would’ve anticipated, the Shakers are also on an actual cup run. Admittedly, it’s not in the FA Cup, which will have to wait for another year, but they are now at their furthest point ever in the much-maligned EFL Trophy, having overcome three League One sides and a full-strength Mansfield away from home in the process. The excellent victory at The Wham Stadium was followed up by an impressive 5-2 demolition of Oxford United at a snowy Gigg Lane. All that stands between them and a first appearance at the ‘new’ Wembley, and the first to a stadium bearing that name in 24 years, are high-flying Portsmouth.
Should the Shakers progress, then it’s almost certain that their crowd will be dwarfed by the contingent Sunderland or Bristol Rovers would bring to London. The reason I mention that is because Shaun Harvey, Chief Executive of the EFL, is incredibly keen for the final to be very well-attended, not just in and of itself, but because it will help to skew the figures/receptiveness of followers of all EFL sides in the competition, and make it appear as though there’s more of an appetite for the current format to continue. Black Cats fans have demonstrated a greater than anticipated enthusiasm for the tournament, so it isn’t especially surprising to read that many opposed to the bungled nature of the tertiary cup want the game to be played between Bury and The Gas.
Encouragingly, a timely announcement was made last Saturday morning of pro terms being agreed and signed by the distinctive-looking playmaker, who has featured on the odd occasion this season in the EFL Trophy, and who started against Leicester City U23s. Lowe has been a big admirer of his from the time he came back to Bury for a third spell, and took the ex-Manchester City youngster under his wing during development games. Having plied his trade with the Blues as a left-sided (but right-footed) wing-back/winger, he’s now someone who takes the initiative in the centre of the park, always looking to dictate the tempo regardless of how high up or far back in midfield he’s positioned. Skillful on the ball, the variety in his passing could see him progress far beyond the confines of Gigg Lane at some point in his future, and his long-range shooting ability makes him most similar in playstyle to O’Shea from the senior squad. The rapport he has with Joe Adams might be something to look out for in 2019/2020.
One more in?
At the time of writing, Sporting Director Lee Dykes has talked about the possibility of adding one further face to the ranks, with perhaps several fringe players joining Scott Burgess on temporary spells away from south Lancashire before the transfer window closes on Thursday.
Burgess’ departure only adds further scrutiny to the area that’s been lacking for a while now – central midfield. It seems very unlikely at this juncture that Callum Styles will rejoin for the remainder of the season, and with Stephen Dawson injured and perhaps unwanted, there really isn’t anyone else that has much first team experience of playing there; O’Connell is now the first alternative to Danns or O’Shea, with Hulme an unlikely second to him. Ryan Cooney can operate in a number of different roles, but seems to be mostly selected at wing-back now.
All of that means a new signing is a distinct possibility, and the likelihood is it would come in the form of a loan. In an ideal world, it would be someone with decent aerial reach, and able to cover a lot of ground. The winter transfer window rarely hands clubs ‘ideals’ when the clock is ticking, and Lowe has recently gone on record to state that if no business can be concluded regarding incomings, he’d still be more than satisfied with the group he already has.
It is around this time of the season that thoughts turn to the final third of league matches, with certain games that appear ‘easier’ on paper proving to be anything but. First up is another home match, this time against Gabriele Cioffi’s Crawley Town. In the reverse tie in Essex, the Shakers conspired to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, but the Red Devils were under Harry Kewell’s management. Since then, the Italian has lost twice the number of games that he’s won. Inconsistency has been the most charitable word to describe their form, but they did break their long winless run on the road last time out at the expense of Swindon Town. Their roster looks a little threadbare at the moment, but in Ollie Palmer, they have someone more than capable of firing them to a comfortable mid-table finish, and he’s already had success against the Shakers this season.
Just before Morecambe away is the small matter of the Fifth Round of the FA Youth Cup, pitting Ryan Kidd’s U18s against Preston North End’s. The two sides have met on three occasions during 2018/2019, with each game ending in a draw. The only difference between them was a penalty shootout victory for Bury in the second of those games (in the Youth Alliance Cup). For the senior side, even with the Shrimps’ form yielding no wins this side of Christmas, they cannot take three points as a given at The Globe Arena. Jim Bentley’s men showed plenty of fight and no shortage of endeavour, and he’ll be calling for those qualities in abundance to avoid relegation once more.
Exeter City have very quietly come back into the play-off reckoning, chiefly at the expense of faltering Colchester United. Jayden Stockley’s sale to the Lillywhites hasn’t yet torpedoed their prospects, but it has hampered their ability to finish chances, with only three strikes thus far in 2019. Avoiding defeat is a must, and opportunities might be a bit more of a premium for the likes of Maynard and O’Shea against a solid-looking defence.
The final league game of the shortest month of the year is the return fixture against Oldham. The Latics remain the only side to have beaten Bury by more than one goal in any competition during 2018/2019, but as ever at Boundary Park these days, it’s hard to know what’s going to happen when they meet again. Under caretaker Pete Wild, they have been at times superb and other times shambolic, with talisman Jose Baxter publicly criticising some of his teammates in the wake of their controversial late defeat to Doncaster Rovers in the FA Cup. Their involvement deep in that tournament does mean they have games in hand over the teams around them, and a late charge for the top seven isn’t out of the question if Wild or his eventual permanent replacement (possibly Paul Scholes) can unify what at times seems like quite a disparate dressing room. Having been humiliated in the first half before Christmas, some of Lowe’s players will now know what’s required of them, especially by fans that want that little bit extra on derby days.
Sky’s cameras will return for the EFL Trophy semi-final match with Pompey. It should be noted that between now and then, the south coast side will have to play at least six games compared to Bury’s four. Still in the hunt for promotion themselves and with a place in the fifth round of the FA Cup at stake, it’s hard to know from the outside how much focus Kenny Jackett will give the televised fixture on the 26th. Whilst it does represent another chance to then play at Wembley, they’re in the middle of a five-team dogfight for two automatic places to the Championship. Lowe’s top priority is understandably also the league, but he too covets the opportunity to lead a side out at the famous stadium. Time will tell if it’s the only chance he’ll get this season…
Analysing The Shakers, League One & Two, and Local English & Welsh Football